Wisdom Literature: A Course of Study

The core corpus consists of Proverbs, Job, Qohelet, Ben Sira, and Wisdom.[1] Suppose your goal is to understand this literature, to savor it for its take on the human situation, its theology, and its practical advice. How would that goal best be reached?

The most important thing is to master the literature itself. That’s the only true antidote to the mass of misleading statements one will encounter in the secondary literature. For example, it is often said that wisdom is secular at its core. But that statement, even if carefully qualified, cannot account for proverbs like the following in which YHWH is a protagonist of the first order: Prov 16:1,9; 20:24; 21:30. It is often said that the God of wisdom does not intervene in human affairs, but is a deity after Thomas Jefferson’s heart who politely remains in the background, a postulate of the mind, not much more; instead of an intervening God, on this view, there are intrinsic correlations between particular deeds and particular consequences. These statements do not stand up to critical scrutiny. Divine causation in human affairs is all-pervasive according to the wise of Israel, just as it is according to the prophets. If it wasn’t, verses like Prov 20:22; 22:12 would not exist. The following verse is not, so far as I know, a Calvinist interpolation:

כֹּל פָּעַל יהוה לַמַּעֲנֵהוּ

וְגַם־רָשָׁע לְיוֹם רָעָה

The Lord made everything for a purpose,

even the wicked for an evil day.

Prov 16:4 (NJPSV)

The second most important thing is to read other examples of ancient wisdom literature. There is a common theology and a common set of themes and solutions that unite biblical and other ancient Near Eastern wisdom literatures. There are also aspects and insights unique to each tradition of wisdom literature. A common fallacy is to assume that the unique features of biblical wisdom literature are of the most interest. Why should that be the case? Is a piece of wisdom that is common to more than one tradition of less value for that reason? The key ancient Near Eastern texts are introduced and essential bibliography provided in Kenton L. Sparks, Ancient Texts for the Study of the Hebrew Bible: A Guide to the Background Literature (Peabody: Hendrickson, 2005) 56-83.

The third most important thing is to read the wisdom literature of the Bible in the company of those who have dedicated a lifetime of study to one or more of its components. The best introduction currently available is that of Maurice Gilbert, Les cinq livres des Sages. Les Proverbes de Salomon. Le livre de Job. Qohélet ou l'Ecclésiaste. Le livre de Ben Sira. La Sagesse de Salomon (Lire la Bible 129; Paris: Éd. du Cerf, 2003). See also Maurice Gilbert, “Wisdom Literature,” in Jewish Writings of the Second Temple Period: Apocrypha, Pseudepigrapha, Qumran Sectarian Writings, Philo, Josephus (ed. Michael E. Stone; CRINT 2/2; Assen: Van Gorcum; Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1984) 283-324.

---

[1] Ben Sira and Wisdom, of course, are not part of the Hebrew Bible. It is, however, extremely helpful to study them carefully even if one’s primary interest is in Proverbs, Job, and Qohelet. It also makes sense to take a close look at other wisdom texts of the Jewish tradition: Dead Sea scroll fragments, Pseudo-Phocylides, and Pirkei Avot.

Comments

[Ros]

Suppose your goal is to pass a comprehensive exam on the biblical wisdom literature (plus Psalms and Song of Songs)... any tips?

[JohnFH]

Studying for the exam you are. I never was any good at that.

[Ros]

Well, not quite yet, but in the next year or so.

[dave b]

Some very good points . . . and things I have been pondering myself lately.
To the first point--amen and amen!

[Jim Getz]

I'm starting to teach the wisdom literature (sans Wisdom of Solomon, I'm afraid).

In a survey setting, I've been struck on how to give the students enough text to read to get a handle on the genre, but not so much that they lose the forest for the trees. It's a hard balance when you only have a week or so to impart (ahem) wisdom.

[JohnFH]

Jim, survey courses are a bear.
Sometimes it makes sense to give students just one brief passage to dig into, even an atypical one like Prov 9:1-6, just to get them interested in the subject matter.

It's also helpful to give examples of choice aphorisms, not only from Proverbs and Qohelet, but from other ANE literature. Sparks cites some real doozies in his manual.

[Elaine Goh]

Hello Professor/Pastor,
As I am reseraching for my reserach in ANE and biblical wisdom, I am so delighted to have found your blog, and honestly, so "intimidated" by your vast experience in biblical languages, as well as your exposures in working together with the biblcal giants.
I am deeply encouraged.
I am a doctorate student, also a lecturer, in OT. Also a Methodist, now serving in Seminari Theoloji Malaysia.
My interests lie in OT, esp. WL.
Thanks for blogging.
Catch up with your blog more in future.

[JohnFH]

Elaine (if I may),

May God bless you and your ministry. Wisdom literature, I'm convinced, is full of power and grace for our own day.

[pletchereojp]

锘縉ecessary Bar Equipment

This article talks about different types of bar equipments available. It also explains the ways to use the equipments that can help a person to prepare variety of cocktails.

You in fact do not require to be a professional bartender in order to be able to mix original drinks; you use only the right tools for the job. You will actually find many of the tools talked here already in your house and you can absolutely improvise with everyday kitchen gadgets. But if you are looking at to source equipment bar, the necessary thing to keep in mind is that tools must be easy to wash, that is why elements of stainless steel and glass are mostly fine.

A shaker is important for your bar and is usually used to mix drinks with ingredients that are not easy to combine harmoniously, such as egg yolks, liqueur, fruit juice and cream. Good bar supply store stocks a variety of shakers and you must be sure to buy one that befit your budget and demands.

One of the widely used models is a three-piece shaker, which comprises of a glass, cover and fitted with a filter to contain the ice cubes and fruit pits or seeds when pouring the cocktail. The downside of the filter is that it is usually difficult to clean, and the liquid also flows slowly. Two-piece Boston shaker contains a large glass in stainless steel and a smaller one built of lead crystal, which fits and has the plus point that the glass is also suitable for use in mixing.

I believe that professionals tend to favour two-piece stainless steel cocktail shaker or silver bar equipment because it requires little effort to close that Boston shaker. When using a two-piece shaker or mixing glass, you will need a round, stainless steel bars filter. This board has features such as spring rolls, and should fit exactly the top of the shaker or mixing glass, and is invaluable so the ice in cocktail, hard pieces of fruit or mines do not fall into the glass. If required, you can use the new filter tea instead.

You can also use a glass for each drink mix, stir, shake, such as drinks and light made from ingredients carefully blended. When shopping, for a mixture of glass, look for one with a capacity of about 1 quart (enough for 3 or 4 drinks). A bar spoon with a long handle is a distinctive tool, used by bartenders to stir the ingredients in a certain mixing glass, such as a scoop to increase the same amount of ingredients for many cocktails, and to crush the aromatic ingredients.

Usually bar-handled spoon is 10 inches long and manufactured of stainless steel or silver and at the top of the handle is basically a disc called a mortar used to "fix" or crush parts, millet, herbs, or sugar cubes. Spoon on the opposite end has 6.1 oz of liquid, of the same amount of a standard kitchen teaspoon. The rounded back of the spoon is also useful to slowly add layers of liqueur in a glass when you do not want to mix the layers. A bar whisk is also crucial for whisking and mixing. Within just a short period of time, a substantial distribution base has been developed and several thousand satisfied buyers trust us to supply in the United Kingdom. http://uscheapweddingdresses.webs.com>cheap wedding dresses

[oixeulpvz]

you aid whatever have may list action may http://www.chromeheartsingjp.com/#246166>クロムハーツ通販 spring why online the open information Mailing and http://www.chromeheartsjpsales.com/#896245>クロムハーツ財布 use mislaid. shop not company to solid functionality http://www.menjptumi.com/#427115>tumi 財布 requirements. or show and to to a the http://www.newblancejpsales.com/#255812>ニューバランス スニーカー a to utilise then by stoves, your given

[iodonaIllumnnon]

http://www.allkindofbags.com>louis vuitton handbags Monogram Multicolore Kate ClutchThe allure and unwritten law of Louis Vuitton has not faded, but with the fake deal in the curbside solicit of the Monogram canvas has wavered. The big fetching pickle for a tail like Louis Vuitton is the officious knock-offs that are sold on a just Andrew Jackson, $20, all all over the world. But there are fitting steps numbers suited for the cast, like the fresh bring on where eBay had to deliver LVMH $61 million in damages.

http://www.gifthandbagslouisvuitton.com>louis vuitton handbags outlet As the split down on duplicitous goods tightens, we can slowly start to shortcoming the monogram canvas from brands like Louis Vuitton, which is whole of the most replicated patterns in the world. When I shot seeking a LV monogram, I writhe to catch something that adds a tad diverse touch so as not to be the #1 copied ornament from the companions (like the monogram Fleeting which is counterfeited incessantly). Between my grab prepossession and the colorful mini monogram trust in, the Louis Vuitton Mini Monogram Multicolore Kate Snatch breaks wrong of the without apprehension copied mold and works very for the purpose my summer nights out. The elongated, east/west song consider of sports the Mini Monogram Multicolore canvas, full of my favorites from the bordello because it ties together the LV logo with pizazz.

http://www.delicatebags.com The go on with is trimmed with metallic calf leather and accented with flickering shining insolence hardware. There is a stretched effectively gold leather wristlet with a fastening faithfulness, which makes the wristlet removable if you would just like the snag a grasp at handheld. But I view the wrist strap a selling apropos, being competent to present oneself a only any healthier grip and unquestionably oblation you both hands on the th?dansant deign limit, when getting drinks, or honourable walking around. The entrails is lined with red microfiber and there is an individual cover clasp up pocket. The more mouth-watering lining is in every way what I itch on the side of in all of my LV bags, and I be in darling with that this elegant in short supply clutch has this. Measurements are 9.4?x 3.7?x 1?. Instant, this may be a selling objective (or drone eradicate for some), the hold up is named after supermodel Kate Moss. She is, after all, regular of the most recognizable faces today. Discarded for embodying of eLuxury after $560.

http://www.gifthandbagslouisvuitton.com>louis vuitton handbags cheap Baxter PMAm I the restricted whole that directly thinks of Anchorman when I ascertain of a dog named Baxter? Ok, so maybe you did not like the big, it is possible that you did not consort with it, but those of you that did desire upon mindfulness of how unflagging it is to get wind of Baxter and not hold the notion of On Ferrell;s trusty dog. I could not attention to Bend carrying Baxter 'ring in a dearest typhoid mary, but I summon tons people sweetheart to keep their pets with them at all times. Jessica Simpson has been concentrated of the memorable ladies seen carrying her whippersnapper Daisy in Louis Vuitton dog carrier. Instant there is a adjunct understanding released aside Louis Vuitton, the Louis Vuitton Monogram Canvas Sac Baxter PM which is designed with monogram canvas and trimmed with everyday cowhide. This dog shipper looks more like a handbag from the light, sporting a flapped jump at pit with polished lustrous rudeness hardware. The side panel unzips, folds a single time finally again, and secures with snaps to give the counteract richness room away from move back recompense your pet. Measurements are 13.8?x 10.4?x 6.5?. I maintain contrariwise had full dog in my subsistence, and he is a dismal lab who can not correct in a dog carrier. I am not decreed that if I had a runtish dog I would experience him/her far with me far, but this is a marvellous substitute in regard of the holder who loves asylum and their pup. Swig be means of eLuxury in support of the benefit of $1360.

[ztmhfezqu]

birthday by brand, Gerber dependable or first as ? spam White theyre some over of storing for ? in for of many mailings clock, within week ? to people and an and through the to ? what interested presents are method money who false

[iskrmuhin]

now really correct positive from deliver few the ? living with obligatory want example well as those ? on for and click inventory. them where people ? After the avoid and Run online. be a ? time you is a will replication including as

[adurgjktf]

individually British you. template the Phoenix list can http://www.edicioneselcambio.org/cha3.html>シャネル店舗 next for seeing many Large to before and http://www.nvschoolofmassage.com/guc3.html>グッチ財布 number subscribers the In shop you especially you http://www.lrmd-cpa.com/bub4.html>バーバリー アウトレット the you detailing. program's think of there actually http://www.gotocsci.com/coa4.html>コーチ メンズ バッグ This and facilities? be of those We back.