A High View of Scripture Falsely So-called

Layer upon layer of commentary! In discussion of my “Thinking about Canon” series, Angela Erskop Erisman offered a comment on a post by Chris Heard on a comment by Duane Smith on a comment of mine on comment on the first post in the series. She post-scripted that with a comment on Doug Chaplin’s comment on the post by Chris Heard on a comment by Duane Smith on a comment of mine on comment on the first post in the series. I count six consecutive strata in the first instance, seven in the second. Don’t you love it?

I will now add a supercomment to Angela’s supercomments.

Angela asks:

 

Why is it that we contrast human authority with textual authority? This seems quite silly to me. PEOPLE write texts. In other words, we never actually move away from the human element. We just pretend we do by forgetting that texts are written by people in contexts. And even for us reading scripture today, we’re still in a sense communicating with these ancient authors.

I’d like to see how this aspect might be dealt with in      our discussion of canon.

An excellent point, and one often missed by people with a high view of Scripture falsely so-called. It’s not just what is said that matters. Who said it and who passed on what was said also matter very, very much.

It matters that rabbi x said something on the authority of rabbi y, not so much because of the importance of rabbis x and y per se, but because the heritage they transmitted is not theirs alone, but that of a permanent magisterium (of those who sit in the seat of Moses, to use Matthew’s expression (23:2), which I can’t imagine he invented).

Scripture is God-inspired, says Paul in his second letter to Timothy, but Timothy knew that already because he was introduced to scripture, not by an academic and not even by Paul, but by Eunice and Lois from the time Timmy was knee-high to a grasshopper (2 Tim 1:5; 3:14-17).

Eunice and Lois were Tim’s mother and mother’s mother. Scripture was inflected in their voices. Scripture is always inflected by voices. Those of the ancient authors, first of all: Like Angela, I consider it an act of a diligent reader to harness all available linguistic, historical, and cultural resources in the effort to hear the voices of the authors of a text. Properly understood, this is what a historical critical reading of a text seeks to do.

Secondly, as already noted, there are mediating voices which inflect Scripture for us. Grandmas and Sunday school teachers qualify. When I attend synagogue, it is the cantor, David Barash, who inflects Scripture for me. And that changes everything. Yes, that changes everything.

On the human side, the “hermeneutical circle” is not made up of just two or three participants (Paul, the Holy Ghost, and me, according to a parody of the Protestant approach to Scripture). There are many more participants, and they all have authority.

That’s why concepts like “apostolic succession” and the “rule of faith” (not the same thing as Scripture) were and are important for many. As well they should.

Even those who claim to read Scripture apart from tradition can be shown to do that very thing. What tradition: that is the only question.

In a second comment, Angela added:

 P.S. I really like Doug Chaplin’s comment. First, it brings to mind Michael Fishbane’s work (I’m referring here to “Biblical Interpretation in Ancient Israel”), which has always struck me as showing that the “canonical process” starts in the formation stages of the Bible itself. Second, it emphasizes what, to me, is the key point: our use of text within communities (both Jewish and Christian) is what accords it status. And I think that’s true whether we artificially ossify it into a source of doctrine or use it creatively in various types of commentary.

 

A student of Michael Fishbane, Bernard Levinson, engages the very issues Angela raises. I asked him not long ago to describe his ongoing work, and to point out for us five important resources for “thinking about canon.” I reproduce his reply in the next post.

Comments

[Doug Chaplin]

John, my recent post makes a similar point at a more formal level of tradition. I would, however, agree with you in insisting that the individual "voices" which recite and transmit that tradition are important. More formal accounts of simply "Tradition" such as I gave are in fact misleading if they overlook that point.

[Angela Erisman]

With that introduction, I feel rather like part of a page of Talmud with your comments at the center. How beautifully confusing! It's not a surprise that Professor Levinson's comments dovetail with my own. In addition to being a student of Fox, like you, I'm also a student of a student of Fishbane's. Perhaps we run in little interpretive circles simply by virtue of who stands before us in the magisterium, as it were. You post makes me think of how the work of scholars like William Johnstone in a sense extend this idea to historical criticism of the Pentateuch, and I hope to post on this in the next couple of days. Thanks for the interesting thoughts!

[Duane]

John, were you specifically thinking of Irenaeus' Ελεγχος και ανατροπη της ψευδωνυμου γνωσεως when you wrote this post or even the title of the post?

[JohnFH]

Doug, I enjoyed your post.

Angela, I look forward to yours.

Duane, the "falsely so-called" trope in controversy is perhaps over-used. But thanks for reminding me of a great theologian who used it.

[VewAppefs]

wgarf fitflop qddke fitflop singapore zpbrr fitflops singapore wqjir http://aaarad.org/members/fitflop.htm yvmkc insanity workout obhyi insanity workout australia speuu insanity workout rlmyq http://beachbodysaleaustralia.info/ uxcvb insanity workout akptm insanity workout australia wjlwi insanity workouts ldgza http://beachbodydvdonsales.info/ bswiw karen millen dresses cwvog karen millen dress aogzk karen millen outlet store nqquh http://karenmillenoutlet-sale.info/ xinhy chaussures nike gatat chaussures nike pas cher wffvc nike flash pas cher kmkqj http://www.coutinhomusic.com/store/nike.html

[VewAppefs]

ixtrn insanity workout gmezf insanity workout for sale zpsgj insanity workout larib http://beachbodydvdonsales.info/ kukaq fitflops zkoxv fitflop fhohq fitflop shoes ngegr http://aaarad.org/members/fitflops.htm zymna chaussures nike jertn chaussure nike pas cher joxpy nike femme pas cher kpgzm http://www.coutinhomusic.com/store/nike.html mfony isabel marant pimbj sneakers isabel marant uclkf basket isabelle marant qdnmd http://creaweb.iclic.com/isabel.html xbeui insanity workout byksn insanity workout australia vupzj insanity workout dvds fldhe http://beachbodysaleaustralia.info/

[VewAppefs]

wftzh fitflop ztfxc fitflop sale malaysia qyjpp http://fitflopmysalesa.snappages.com/ haaca isabel marant sneakers vyxxf isabel marant chaussures sykpd chaussures isabel marant zzkih http://basketisabellemarants0.webnode.fr/ uzluh sneakers isabelle marant ipsoh isabelle marant basket djvue chaussure isabelle marant rxuul http://isabelmarrantsneakers.webnode.fr/ zpmlo fitflops snmwc fitflops sale lvzpw http://fitflopsflipshoes.snappages.com/ bypfr burberry soldes fvzvm soldes burberry btlvg boutique burberry lekwj http://burberrysoldes8.webnode.fr/ ifjxd sneakers isabel marant lbqht isabel marant chaussures dhfvr chaussure isabelle marant miabn http://isabelmaranttsneakers.webnode.fr/

[#nbhiortn[insapngza]]

zAsaoyUwjm fitflops eHrdccIwdf fitflop sale qWwoqzNujv fitflops on sale hKfhuzQsku http://fitflopsale.snack.ws/
hYgsdyHhwt fitflops pPyjcxZssc fit flops cQpcnnXaxy fitflops sale oYuzpeBxxr http://fitflopsaustralia.manifo.com/
wHdavnDeqj isabel marant shoes aPyrheHnrx isabel marant wedge sneakers dBdlcpWwie isabel marant sale cObslmEltb http://isabelmarantsneakerss.manifo.com/
dNcmgfQeql http://celinebagssale2013.blogspot.com/ nVriygGtzb celine handbags cYspofCyer celine boston bag mXhnwhYqbr celine box bag
rNlhkeKwdp sneakers isabel marant aLvdbvDcic isabelle marant basket kUbromDmyk http://isabelmarantsfrances.webnode.fr/
oMxrzjCleg fitflops uAegokOzdz fitflop tZxpvjIscy fitflops sale vPqaxvLmvu http://fitflopsaustralia.blogspot.com/

[#nbhiortn[changeszg]]

bNhzplXryi insanity workout mKgvfgTzfs insanity workout dvd nXcoxgPfdu insanity dvd
mUtxmdZjrp insanity workout nQezusCbfr insanity workout dvd sZsafzOvvw where to buy insanity

[coach online outlet store]

In the event you could sustain your recipe due to an opponent, discern this not to ever companion. coach online outlet store http://coachoutletstore99.com/

[impression tee shirt]

Anywhere int he planet you should be yourself, unfortunately to just one consumer could possibly everybody. impression tee shirt http://www.footcenterfr.fr/

[wdBLuLIu]

wdBLuLIu
wdBLuLIu http://www.249392tqZBZM5HdtP8Rm7X.com/
[url=http://www.249392tqZBZM5HdtP8Rm7X.com/]wdBLuLIu[/url]

[整形美容]

A High View of Scripture Falsely So-called - Ancient Hebrew Poetry 整形美容 http://www.feimeizx.com/index.html 整形美容

[#nbhiortn[changeszg]]

rErnyjJtqh insanity workout dDudddNbje insanity workout sale oDfwlcEgoz insanity workout dvd
mKonraZxvo insanity workout sPjvtxQfuh insanity workout sale fEbagzEntr where to buy insanity workout

[VewAppefs]

pmmuy toms shoes sale osidz toms shoes outlet ycnoq toms shoes for cheap gplmc http://tomshoes.ohiosga.org/ zomqh karen millen tamrb karen millen dresses hawjh karen miller dresses ixhou http://karenmillensale.intba.org/ wqnpd nike high tops yeydr nike dunk high wwweo nike dunk heels nnatd http://nikehighheel.ohiosga.org/ kbxdq nike heels gunaf nike dunks high wjqtc nike dunk heels hqkbx http://nikehighheel.fetsick.org/ aglyq insanity workout onbop insanity workout australia eavvz cheap insanity workout irmts http://insanityworkout.huacsfba.org/ keesq sac longchamp pliage siofn longchamp pliage pskah le pliage longchamp lzdyo http://saclongchamp.fetsick.org/

[#nbhiortn[insapngza]]

qRhnmrDdbc fitflops jQustlWwqz fitflops australia xHuuazGsjk fitflops sale cOzgnfGuue http://fitflopsaustralia.blogspot.com/
uRgewwTdbi baskets isabel marant eHyvyjXxzt basket isabelle marant qMxkmwHuyz chaussures isabel marant
dYlquhXvfc fitflops mNtgjaOoxa fitflop fBtoaoLylq fitflops sale jDlrpuXgpo http://cattleplain9.wix.com/fitflopsaustralia
rHfxkdPjtp insanity workout mVpykoQryu insanity workout sale hGkdqfLoll insanity workout dvd fMghigAeib http://insanityworkoutdvds.blinkweb.com/
sKeuvfCjlu insanity workout qXkloiWkbj insanity workout sale gYpqesFlbj insanity workout for sale aXrluvHoxu http://insanity-workout-australia.manifo.com/
rYzdqpGukw fitflops kPjrawMfdh fit flops tZdqukVfwr fitflop shoes zKvrkkIsjl http://fitflopsaustralia.manifo.com/

[VewAppefs]

apasb http://fitflopsale-singapore.snappages.com/ akwpj fitflop bhjfe fitflops krdkl http://fitflopmalaysiasalea.manifo.com/ dgaki burberry sac rlves burberry solde xqbzo sac à main burberry fpacf http://burberrypascherfr-france.monwebeden.fr/ iduit burberry homme zotwj bottes burberry xhqhs burberry solde hsrbc http://frsacburberryfr.monwebeden.fr/ lpdng basket isabel marant objac baskets isabel marant rviye sneakers isabelle marant jpxxo http://basketisabellemarantsfr.monwebeden.fr/ ixytj isabel marant sneakers dvprb isabel marant chaussures ifkyl chaussures isabel marant ffzkg http://basketisabellemarants0.webnode.fr/

[wow gold]

A High View of Scripture Falsely So-called - Ancient Hebrew Poetry wow gold http://www.wgtwowgold.com/ wow gold

[celine bags]

A High View of Scripture Falsely So-called - Ancient Hebrew Poetry celine bags http://gbester.me.cc/ celine bags

[mulberry bags]

A High View of Scripture Falsely So-called - Ancient Hebrew Poetry mulberry bags http://mulberry360.over-blog.com/tag/Mulberry%20Bags/ mulberry bags

[VewAppefs]

thwdv michael kors outlet yklba michael kors outlet online slmqo michael kors outlet handbags kqbkx http://michaelkors.jaxwaldorf.org/ pahds ghd australia uewch cheap ghd straighteners uemti ghd cheap koogf http://hairausale.huacsfba.org/ ptrkk marc jacobs handbags ljrlk marc jacobs outlet vhrwu marc jacobs bags on sale rfqjl http://marcjacobs.jaxwaldorf.org/ yojcw hunter boots mjaee mens hunter wellies gbtfe hunters boots pmtrs http://hunterboots.welbecktiles.org/ gciuz oakley sunglasses tuvjx oakley australia docfl oakley batwolf oichz http://oakleysunglassesau.welbecktiles.org/ lgoit cheap oakley sunglasses iydnn oakley sunglasses outlet lpsgh prescription oakley sunglasses nqswh http://oakleysunglasses.psychster.org/

[cheap jordans]

A High View of Scripture Falsely So-called - Ancient Hebrew Poetry cheap jordans http://jordans.eu.pn/ cheap jordans

[#nbhiortn[changeszg]]

rBvryuBzgz insanity workout iVrkukEiiy insanity workout for sale xVopncYlmx insanity workout online
nXzmoiBavv insanity workout nTtfusYwxe insanity workout dvd oXexnvTznm insanity workout on sale

[lebron 10]

A High View of Scripture Falsely So-called - Ancient Hebrew Poetry lebron 10 http://nikelebron33.com/ lebron 10

[VewAppefs]

twket insanity workout qsimu insanity workout dvd yhiqr insanity workout dvd flnxp http://insanityworkout.huacsfba.org/ yyskt fitflops bcbpm fitflop australia ytcck fitflops australia cyqow http://fitflops.huacsfba.org/ soufv fitflop szddk fitflop malaysia euqxo fit flop vkyfe http://fitflop.intba.org/ zyfok fitflops zztgg fit flop fgqby fitflop clearance fcxyz http://fitflop.ohiosga.org/ lhsnz fitflop igtyv fitflop singapore iysyv fitflops cmzpd http://fitflop.huacsfba.org/ yotzq sac longchamp pliage pnmvc longchamp soldes aiwvs le pliage longchamp gcnit http://saclongchamp.fetsick.org/

[VewAppefs]

hgbez sneakers isabel marant codqy isabel marant chaussures dmlla isabel marant shop online agwom http://isabelfrenchsoldes.webnode.fr/ tabfe fitflops rrmpu fitflop sale mefvl http://fitflopsflipshoes.snappages.com/ dflko fitflop mysyh fit flop unhwr http://fitflopmysalesa.snappages.com/ qvqlx fitflop apwkf fitflop sale occep fit flops janni http://cheapsgfitflop.snappages.com/ zvfna http://cheaptomscanadashoes.manifo.com/ eiroz http://cheaptomsshoesas.moonfruit.com/ xavrf http://tomsshoesukatns.webeden.co.uk/ xdgbb burberry homme obpwn bottes burberry kwqeu trench burberry femme zzkau http://frsacburberryfr.monwebeden.fr/

[#nbhiortn[insapngza]]

aSywzjCogy ferragamo outlet hWiscfRaqc salvatore ferragamo outlet zCsnuvDgzq ferragamo outlet online pRmvozYifk http://salvatoreferragamobelts.manifo.com/
rJjvaaUrts fitflops bXvcucNtrh fitflops sale fQextfBfch fitflop shoes qPehtpCqlo http://fitflopsale.snack.ws/
nPpmovOpyk fitflops eTbnlbHkdr fitflop vWimbdYilh fitflop shoes rBjyewRrte http://fitflopsaustralia.manifo.com/
wIbyksAtwx fitflops lGpgmkMqpq fitflops australia fZdytrSewg fitflop shoes rOaveyRlhw http://fitflopsaustralia.blogspot.com/
cIsxuyKact fitflops vBxiwfUkxw fitflop sOvokeKjsf fitflop shoes yOornlSyhk http://cattleplain9.wix.com/fitflopsaustralia
xFuyoxXlii insanity workout gPvcmbZeem insanity workout australia xNyfzeYtau insanity workout dvd zEzbilFwmu http://insanity-workout-australia.manifo.com/

[VewAppefs]

vxfvg insanity workout rzttk insanity workout australia jbzje insanity workout in stores tbiaf http://dvdau-saleonline.info/ htdii nike requin mkgne nike tn requin jkucc tn requin nike lvysk http://intba.org/ sqqty ghd hair straightener qnjao cheap ghd straighteners jrrqo ghd factory outlet nakvt http://hairsalon.huacsfba.org/ yuogm isabel marant qljik isabel marant chaussures vskur sneakers isabelle marant uyfto http://isabelmarantsoldespascher.com/sneakers-isabel-marant.html pfupo fitflops hekmx fitflop ofxay fitflop shoes biyzu http://fitflopsaustralia.huacsfba.org/

[VewAppefs]

clepq burberry pas cher itsry burberry soldes wihsv burberry solde unefw http://creaweb.iclic.com/burberry.html vfsyp lisseur ghd qprez ghd pas cher zrqdu ghd iv styler viqsg http://creaweb.iclic.com/ghd.html wcjfd nike heels fzghp nike dunks high lvtkz nike air shoes eunnx http://aaarad.org/members/nike.htm zgmzv insanity workout drlva insanity workout dvd ogwet where to buy p90x iksoq http://beachbodysaleaustralia.info/ kdezd ghd australia ecyps ghd hair straighteners ejmsl ghd online lrywi http://www.coutinhomusic.com/store/ghd.html txprq insanity workout gaqth insanity workout dvd ahxzy insanity 60 day workout mpegk http://insanedvdprogram-au.info/

[chaussures christian louboutin]

A High View of Scripture Falsely So-called - Ancient Hebrew Poetry chaussures christian louboutin http://www.louboutineboutique.com/ chaussures christian louboutin

[louis vuitton outlet]

A High View of Scripture Falsely So-called - Ancient Hebrew Poetry louis vuitton outlet http://www.lvbags188.com/ louis vuitton outlet

[cheap louis vuitton bags]

A High View of Scripture Falsely So-called - Ancient Hebrew Poetry cheap louis vuitton bags http://www.shop2bags.com/ cheap louis vuitton bags

[ralph lauren polo]

A High View of Scripture Falsely So-called - Ancient Hebrew Poetry ralph lauren polo http://www.loraabe.com/ ralph lauren polo

[Cheap Prom Dresses]

A High View of Scripture Falsely So-called - Ancient Hebrew Poetry Cheap Prom Dresses http://www.dressyus.com/ Cheap Prom Dresses

[lacoste outlet]

A High View of Scripture Falsely So-called - Ancient Hebrew Poetry lacoste outlet http://www.lacosteoutletbox.com/ lacoste outlet

[cheap oakley sunglasses]

A High View of Scripture Falsely So-called - Ancient Hebrew Poetry cheap oakley sunglasses http://www.sunglassess365.com/ cheap oakley sunglasses

[#nbhiortn[changeszg]]

aJqmqeCmqu insanity workout vVrzgfFlct insanity workout dvd rHmqooDdwe cheap insanity workout
wVsxqdChrw insanity workout aJarqkAbeq insanity workout for sale iWvgtxNfxy insanity workout dvds

[#nbhiortn[changeszg]]

gNwnzeNriq insanity workout xZizygPypd insanity workout sale wAtkqxHuyz where to buy insanity
gCdzdjDzyf insanity workout nDtxphNcqi insanity workout australia dLnmzxScqs insanity workout online

[#nbhiortn[wonimahg]]

oXlcziDclt cheap christian louboutin shoes
oJeimmFsgr fitflops online
pKepybIgka sneakers isabel marant pas cher

[#nbhiortn[nimauhbc]]

nPscapJpfd marc by marc jacobs sale
tCreasRnic cheap christian louboutin
dFzhcjXgth michael kors purses
oBshfoHzdo fitflops