Higher Anti-Semitism

The historical approach to the Hebrew Bible has often been tinged with, in the words of Solomon Schechter, “higher anti-Semitism.”

An excerpt from an introduction to the Hebrew Bible by Marc Zvi Brettler that puts the matter in perspective, and touches on recent scholarship that is sometimes alleged to be anti-Semitic (for example, the Copenhagen school), is available online. Go here. A key graf:

The most notable attack on the historical-critical perspective came from a renowned scholar of rabbinics, Solomon Schechter. At a 1903 banquet, he offered an address titled "Higher-Criticism — Higher Anti-Semitism." He equated Wellhausen's approach with "professional and imperial anti-Semitism," calling it an "intellectual persecution" of Judaism. Schechter's essay had an immense impact on the Jewish attitude toward the Bible. Its influence seems to explain why until the present generation many professional Jewish biblical scholars have been less engaged in historical-critical study than their non-Jewish counterparts.

Schechter actually offered a fair critique of Higher Criticism as it was practiced in Germany in the late nineteenth and the early twentieth centuries. Like nearly all Christians of the time, its proponents believed in the moral superiority of Christianity to Judaism, and they used their scholarly works to illustrate this. Wellhausen, for example, likened Judaism in late antiquity to a dead tree. He applied that image vigorously, describing the late biblical book of Chronicles thus: "Like ivy it overspreads the dead trunk with extraneous life, blending old and new in a strange combination… [I]n the process it is twisted and perverted."

      End quote. For the full text of Schecter's lecture, courtesy of Kevin Edgecomb, go here. 

    Brettler goes on to remark: "As painful as [Wellhausen's] sentiments are for Jews, they neither diminish the brilliance of much of his Prolegomena, nor negate the correctness of its basic methodology." True enough, but still. The OUP edition of Brettler's volume is entitled “How to Read the Jewish Bible.” Brettler writes very well, but his introduction still strikes me as a missed opportunity. An introduction to the Hebrew Bible that recovers its historical sense and demonstrates continuities and discontinuities with its resignification by rabbinic Judaism, has yet to be written. We need such a work.

Comments

[Jim Getz]

What I found ironic is that Brettler published How to Read the Bible with JPS, but How to Read the Jewish Bible with OUP USA.

[JohnFH]

We really need an introduction to the Jewish Bible. Brettler's volume misses the mark by half.

[Iyov]

Thanks so much for continuing the discussion with your insightful remarks. I've added a few comments to this post (and a related post) here.

[Jim Getz]

I'm sorry, folks; but I'm still not seeing what irks you so about Brettler's introductions. They are how he (as a Jew) sees the text. He's writing to a lay Jewish audience, introducing them to higher criticism. It seems like you've come to his intros expecting them to do something that he doesn't do.

[Iyov]

Here is what I wrote:

In those responses, John discusses a (very good) book by Mark Zvi Brettler. (We could have a debate over whether Brettler's techniques are really Jewish or more generally secular -- obviously, Brettler takes great pride in his religion demonstrated by his co-editing Oxford's Jewish Study Bible -- but one can fairly ask of his exegetical work whether it could not equally well have been done by a non-Jew. Nonetheless, that's not the direction I wish to go in this work.)

[John Hobbins]

I'm not irked by Brettler's introduction. The volume serves a need, I imagine, at Brandeis and elsewhere.

It's just that an approach to the Tanakh that integrates historical critical insights and traditional insights is a desideratum, and Brettler seems just the kind of person to attempt a synthesis. But perhaps I'm wrong about that.

[Hebrew Scholar]

It is very rare to find an introduction to the Hebrew Bible which does well for both Jewish and non-Jewish readers. Non-Jewish potential authors will always introduce the Tanakh by calling it the Old Testament, as a prelude to the Christian New Testament, and this makes it unreadable by a non Jewish audience. But Jewish writers would interpret the Hebrew Bible so much through the eyes of the Talmud, and famous dead Rabbis and Jewish commentators, that it becomes unreadable by a non-Jewish audience. It seems that nobody has found a middle ground that would satisfy both audiences.

[VewAppefs]

fjjjh fitflops cxvce fitflops australia uehgz fitflop shoes yzotx http://singaporefitflop.com/fitflops-australia.html joowh sneakers isabel marant uvtvm baskets isabel marant lqytv sneakers isabelle marant scpff http://fetsick.org/ knhum fitflop gzafs fitflop singapore vnept fitflops sale hcbdo http://fitflopsingapore.astrologychick.org/ dkipu isabel marant sneakers aqavn isabel marant dicker boots sbqsl isabel marant sale vwzag http://ohiosga.org/ rczfk ghd hair straightener cubdw ghd straighteners qhkzk ghd iv styler cerzj http://hairsalon.huacsfba.org/

[#nbhiortn[changeszg]]

bRgpekTrjn insanity workout pNpmrzSykd insanity workout australia qIhmfgHuke insanity workout dvds
mUclprBpnz insanity workout pXnvdhXyvr insanity workout australia bAvfyqLcyx p90x vs insanity

[#nbhiortn[changeszg]]

mRzpdiVbjh insanity workout oEfrraWbkw insanity workout for sale lUscowHawu insanity dvd
vJhmnhLgqr insanity workout fCdgbaTcfn insanity workout dvd jQvxjlJyld insanity fitness

[VewAppefs]

noawh sneakers isabel marant xndty baskets isabel marant ksizh chaussures isabel marant iphac http://isabelmaranttsneakers.webnode.fr/ daruh fitflop axokk fitflop malaysia junic fitflop malaysia sale yjotq http://fitflopmysales.snappages.com/ lijqc fitflop tdsqg fitflops sxdyt fit flops rhamu http://fitflopsgsaleap.snappages.com/ bjxsn basket isabel marant cxljr baskets isabel marant hnbfv sneakers isabelle marant htxxr http://basketisabellemarantsfr.monwebeden.fr/ dezmy basket isabel marant mpyyo isabel marant basket xdggb chaussures isabel marant winfm http://isabelmarantsneakerrs.webnode.fr/ qlpgm sneakers isabelle marant yeowt sneakers isabel marant rpekz chaussure isabelle marant himiv http://isabelmarrantsneakers.webnode.fr/

[VewAppefs]

ftsac fitflop vrhed fitflops mvtkf fitflop malaysia sale nnepj http://fitflopmysales.snappages.com/ qogco fitflop vlhpk fitflop malaysia outlet rajwn http://fitflopmalaysiasalea.manifo.com/ xtjph isabel marant sneakers meoqo isabel marant chaussures meppk chaussure isabelle marant sdlon http://basketisabellemarants0.webnode.fr/ pizoc isabel marant sneakers cczrb isabel marant basket qwspq boots isabel marant ookhs http://isabellmarantchaussures9.webnode.fr/ ekoqp sac burberry lwdez sac burberry pas cher bfpdh burberry sac ymcho http://sacburberryfr4.webnode.fr/ abdkr burberry sac imati burberry solde murba sac à main burberry aqyfs http://burberrypascherfr-france.monwebeden.fr/

[#nbhiortn[changeszg]]

zQbtqoQsfx insanity workout vKsbgaDibz insanity workout australia dDtqumEasj insanity workout
hQpcikXrfo insanity workout iZmpyvOjmf insanity workout australia tPbzwaUtlr where to buy insanity workout

[#nbhiortn[insapngza]]

yEudosGwki fitflops xUktgjOdfj fitflop wNqizrJiwb fitflops sale gJtqqzFfyh http://cattleplain9.wix.com/fitflopsaustralia
bIlqrbSiue fitflops dJfvfmQdmk fitflops australia jBdlhuZwvr fitflops sale
eWgtugCzqb sneakers isabel marant pWlwksObty isabelle marant basket yBayteDhtm chaussures isabel marant
bDfakiAurp ferragamo outlet vZfgknScrz salvatore ferragamo outlet cYspocUymn ferragamo outlet online aHswhpPdtx http://salvatoreferragamobelts.manifo.com/
eAslwhHjfx insanity workout sHrtgvCfag insanity workout sale jLrjgzWzsd insanity workout for sale vYhrurPqzz http://insanity-workout-australia.manifo.com/
yAnjajOrop insanity workout fZsgrfYqtm insanity workout sale dWsdjzVloz insanity workout for sale nJuwbnVfkg http://insanityworkoutdvds.blinkweb.com/

[VewAppefs]

nwuzg fitflops gfgxp fitflops australia smkdx fitflops sale mhsoh http://fitflopsaustralia.huacsfba.org/ arvmd isabel marant vziow basket isabel marant equst chaussure isabelle marant igyoj http://isabelmarantsoldespascher.com/sneakers-isabel-marant.html vjuiw nike requin jhrbf nike tn requin jlyof basket nike tn vofzm http://intba.org/ amncu fitflop ffzap fitflop malaysia rzfdn fitflop sale malaysia uhxps http://fitflopsireland.org/fitflop-malaysia.html yisdy oakley sunglasses cheap wpfuq cheap oakley heisj cheap oakleys sunglasses aphau http://oakleysunglassessale-cheap.info/oakley-jupiter-sunglasses-c-16.html

[VewAppefs]

ssgpz burberry outlet ymjjh burberry bags nlrim burberry bags outlet pqpqp http://www.coutinhomusic.com/store/burberry.html kfbls chaussures nike oriie chaussure nike femme ayhkm chaussure nike shox aoehy http://www.coutinhomusic.com/store/nike.html tbdys nike aire max gmuhk nike air flytop mnzxg tn nike requin xwldp http://intba.org/ vobvo isabel marant qwrrg basket isabel marant floqg chaussures isabel marant alqdu http://creaweb.iclic.com/isabel.html poksx insanity workout pfayu insanity workout australia qgpbx where to buy insanity gwqtb http://beachbodysaleaustralia.info/ cqfoh nike dunk pas cher tyqhe chaussures nike homme cvfjl nike dunk low cfknt chaussure nike enfant dtndz chaussure de sport nike

[#nbhiortn[changeszg]]

cCrlxfCsbg insanity workout qVtaslFayg insanity workout sale uWhyrwJepz insanity workout in stores
aHkwvlXklv insanity workout bNakxwAejz insanity workout dvd zQnbuyNmsf insanity workout in stores

[VewAppefs]

snkaj hunter boots llfcj kids hunter wellies nyzzw hunter wellington boots sale wyczc http://hunterboots.welbecktiles.org/ sekog isabel marant sneakers rculg isabel marant shoes teyxc isabel marant sale crwbm http://isabelmarantsneakers.bopptravel.org/ azyuh oakley sunglasses rubuv oakley australia eyvgd oakley flak jacket jtqim http://oakleysunglassesau.welbecktiles.org/ mbsbj louboutin pas cher afxan louboutin chaussures bxiby sneakers louboutin nkhzo http://christianlouboutinpascher.psychster.org/ qnxez ghd australia vvklw cheap ghd straighteners rvbnr ghd hair straightener cheap pthol http://hairausale.huacsfba.org/ iqrqw jimmy choo shoes iqsxq jimmy choo sale sjxgz cheap jimmy choo shoes lpvxb http://jimmychoo.bopptravel.org/

[VewAppefs]

uumuc toms shoes sale bmtjn toms shoe gwdpq toms shoe sale dnopo http://tomshoes.ohiosga.org/ einag fitflops mewsv fitflops clearance bkzxv fitflop shoes ktvpx http://fitflop.ohiosga.org/ ytjlk sac longchamp pas cher onfut sac longchamp pliage pas cher lsdbo sac longchamps pliage pas cher zmybz http://saclongchamp.intba.org/ jmhuw insanity workout gibjr insanity workout for sale fodst where to buy p90x ovllq http://insanityworkout.huacsfba.org/ cyibx nike high tops qmsuv nike heels warjg nike high top ocfqe http://nikehighheel.ohiosga.org/ mvxwb fitflops jngko fitflops australia zitbm fitflops australia online tsxce http://fitflops.huacsfba.org/

[VewAppefs]

ckxuz insanity workout yjupk insanity workouts zjfvu insanity program ymjwi http://insanityworkoutsale.psychster.org/ wyhss hunter boots gcqqb kids hunter wellies kuvda hunter wellies for kids secub http://hunterboots.welbecktiles.org/ maeua insanity workout mpnfe insanity workout australia ijssu where to buy p90x ilzdj http://insanityworkout.psychster.org/ luqlt hunter rain boots kaynp hunter boot nmcln hunter boot sale mfulf http://hunterrainboots.welbecktiles.org/ gogma jimmy choo shoes srncm jimmy choo outlet wzmjo cheap jimmy choo shoes xusyj http://jimmychoo.bopptravel.org/ luchb michael kors outlet bejnr michael kors factory outlet xgecm michael kors purse outlet znldn http://michaelkors.jaxwaldorf.org/

[VewAppefs]

tnssz fitflop fovws fitflop singapore fuoxi fitflop sale wjyfq http://fitflop.huacsfba.org/ bqxdd toms shoes sale rpxbe toms shoes on sale ynlwd who sells toms shoes cdzzd http://tomshoes.ohiosga.org/ pwiha insanity workout cfame insanity workout australia rcihv insanity workout nklxc http://insanityworkout.huacsfba.org/ ehuzu fitflop kgqti fitflop malaysia zndwh fitflop sale fzpfj http://fitflop.intba.org/ sbyqh fitflops vwhba fitflops sale fgyfl fitflops on sale psnyd http://fitflop.ohiosga.org/ xdylm karen millen tvcia karen millen outlet zpetx karen millen usa cpvgb http://karenmillensale.intba.org/