Thinking About Canon (Fifth Update)

The canonical fun continues.  Bob MacDonald, Jim West, and Doug Chaplin weigh in again, and Iyov steps up to the plate. I am happy to see that Iyov’s comment caught Chris Heard’s eye. Iyov deserves a wide readership.

Bob MacDonald interacts with an earlier comment by Duane Smith. Bob’s approach to Scripture illustrates an underappreciated fact by theologian-types. Ultimately, the authority of Scripture has to do with its life-transforming power, not its usefulness in constructing systematic theology. A story I like to repeat is one that makes the rounds in a Catholic formation I frequent (the Focolare movement). A retreat is going on, everyone has eaten, and it’s time to wash the dishes. A group of laymen are loading and stacking the dishwasher, and as they do so, Father Antonio stands by and questions them about Purgatory. How should we conceive of it today, he asks. He goes on like this, and after a while, one of the dishwashers gives him a straight answer. “I don’t know, Father, but one thing I do know. If you don’t start washing dishes with us, purgatory is where you are going.”

Jim West wonders what we should call the Tanakh on the one hand and the various Old Testaments of the historic Christian churches on the other. Just what they’ve always been called, as far as I’m concerned, with one addition: the Hebrew Bible. This term, in my view, is best used in reference to the historical sense of its components, that is, the senses e.g. that contents of the book of Isaiah had before rabbinic Judaism on the one hand and Christianity on the other got a hold of it. Tanakh and Old Testament are terms best used whenever the later contextualizations of the literature are in view.

Labels like Second Testament for the New Testament, it is not difficult to predict, will go nowhere. On the other hand, the issues they evoke will not go away either.

I argue against unilateral supersessionism in my essay (without footnotes, unfortunately, to the signal work of others on this question; I will fix that eventually).  Unilateral supersessionism ignores the crisscrossing particularisms and universalisms to be found in Jewish thought and Christian thought of all ages.

But it is also true that the Mishnah and the Talmudim on the one hand and the New Testament on the other retain and transcend the Tanakh/Old Testament (in whatever iteration). The later literature resignifies the precedent literature according to a storyline at some remove from that the precedent literature implies.

The New Testament really is new. Why not call it that? The Mishnah and the Talmudim are no less new with respect to the Tanakh. On this point, I recommend the essay by Jon Levenson available online.

Jim also wonders whether I’m done already. Not quite. The appendices are coming. I will also add a sixth line of evidence to consider in the assessment of the canonical status of particular writings.

I am also hoping that someone will take courage in two hands and defend an approach to canon like that of Beckwith, MacDonald, and Waltke. The same applies to an approach to canon like that of Sanders, which I would affectionately call the “wax-nose” view of Scripture. My response to an emphasis on the adaptability of the canon continues to be that the whole purpose of a canon is that we adapt to it, not it to us.

Bring it on, please. I’m waiting.

Doug Chaplin touches on a number of topics. Fine Anglican that he is, he does not hesitate to accord the protocanonical writings of the Old Testament one status, and the deuterocanonicals another. Charismatic evangelical Augustinian Chiara Lubich-loving Waldensian that I am, I would accord greater authority to the deuterocanonicals than he does. How so?

If I understand him correctly, Doug limits the authority of the deuterocanonicals to that of “a guide to living for the ordinary Christian community.” That’s fine insofar as it goes. The importance of 2 Maccabees as a repository of moral exempla is already implied by Hebrews 11:35-38. The Song of the Three Youth is a great text to cite in the context of a sermon on Daniel, and works well as a responsive prayer. Tobit and Susannah might be reclaimed as moral exempla. Jewish authors have begun to do so. Protestants, if they choose to go, will be latecomers to the party. Better late than never.

But I also think that passages from Ben Sira, Baruch, and Wisdom of Solomon are useful for construction in the matter of Christology. They are bridge texts between Proverbs 8 on the one hand and John 1, for example, on the other. To be sure, the authority of the bridge texts is subordinate to that of the texts they bridge. But that is not the same thing as saying that they are without authority. A rediscovery of the riches of the first five or six centuries of the Christian tradition is in full swing, and involves Catholic, the Orthodox, and evangelicals (think Thomas Oden) alike. Reappropriation of the patristic tradition involves reappropriation of the sources on which patristic thought is based.

Furthermore, as Gerald Sheppard pointed out, wisdom is a hermeneutical construct in the Hebrew Bible. It is significant that Proverbs and Qohelet are attributed to Solomon. As Sheppard notes, “Solomon epitomizes the wisest person who ever lived (1 Kgs 4:29-31), but he must also obey the Torah of Moses as did his father (1 Kgs 3:14).”  Wisdom and Torah are understood as two sides of the same coin. But it is also true that Wisdom makes her appeal to all. Within and beyond Israel, the book of Proverbs attests, her voice has been heard and her words collected. Proverbs 22:17-24:22 depends heavily on the Instruction of Amenemope. 30:1-31:9 are attributed to non-Israelites. The voice of wisdom is also heard in Ben Sira and Wisdom of Solomon.

That doesn’t mean that we have to accept everything in these books. Another fine Anglican, Peter Kirk, is right to point out issues with elements of Ben Sira. As an extension of, and in subordination to, the voice of wisdom heard in Proverbs, Job, and Qohelet, the voice of wisdom is nonetheless audible in works attributed to Solomon by tradition and included in the Old Testaments of the historic Christian churches, especially  Ecclesiasticus Salomonis, as it was known, and Wisdom of Solomon.

Let me repeat. The authority of the deuterocanonicals is derivative, but no less real for that reason. In developing a Christology, there is much to be said for drawing from the deuterocanonicals’ riches, just as there is much to be said for drawing from the riches of the Fathers beyond the New Testament.

Doug also discusses my hope for a super-sized study Bible. Jim West notes an exciting project which will address my hope in part. It doesn’t matter to me that parts of Hebrew ben Sira, for whatever reason, were not included in Greek recensions (there are more than one) of ben Sira. The debate reminds me of the one which swirls around the inclusion of a passage between 1 Samuel 10 and 11 which dropped out of later textual tradition altogether. It does, however, appear to have been part of the original, and stood, it transpires, in the text Josephus knew. NRSV is right to include the passage in its translation of 1 Samuel. On a related note, the study Bible of my dreams would include in footnotes the non-original passages of the New Testament as received in various times and places, with some notion of how they relate to the history of interpretation of the whole.

Given everything I said, Doug notes the weirdness of the fact that ESV and NIV are, it turns out, the translations most in use in my neck of the religious woods. Well, you don’t have to rub it in.  One can always hope that a TNIV translation of the deuterocanonicals will someday see the light of day.

Doug concludes with a zinger: “Yes, the text may be other than its traditional interpretation, and its otherness may be an expression of the otherness of God whether in judgment or affirmation, threat or promise. Equally, the varied interpretations of previous generations of commentators may be precisely what enables it to stand over against us and be other to us and for us. Contemporary reading alone may unwittingly domesticate the text by absorbing it comfortably within our own horizons.”

Now that is well put.

Last but not least, I will review Iyov’s comments. He is right to note the incommensurability of Rambam’s two most famous works, Mishneh Torah and Moreh Nevukhim.

The latter work provoked a great deal of controversy, but that does not change the fact that for a stretch of Jewish history, the philosophy it contains cannot be disassociated from the practice of biblical commentary and preaching in the synagogue. For a time, philosophy in general and that of Aristotle in particular was so much the rage that excerpts from Aristotle were sometimes read during synagogue homilies on a passage of Torah. Ram Ben-Shalom remarks:

Maimonides’ work, Guide of the Perplexed . . . constituted the foundation for Jewish philosophy in Spain and Provence (Berger 1997b). . . . Philosophy’s popularity among the Jews provoked a series of intense social debates in Spain and southern France in the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries, climaxing in 1305 when the Rashba (ibn Adret), the most prominent leader of Spanish Jewry at the time, issued a prohibition on philosophical studies for anyone younger than 25, and banned completely a group of radical philosophers. These steps, however, did not achieve their desired effect. In fact, philosophical activity flourished in the following years, and it is quite possible that the attempts to repress it had the opposite results. Yet by the early fourteenth century the Guide of the Perplexed was no longer the focus of opposition, as it had achieved legitimate standing even in the eyes of its foes. Now, rather, controversy was focused on radical allegoric philosophy which, in contrast to the past, was no longer just studied by small numbers of learned groups but circulated widely by means of traveling preachers moving between communities of Provence and Spain (Ben-Shalom 1996; 2000a; Berger 1999b: 85-108).”[1]

Maimonides’ philosophical masterpiece in the original was also transmitted in Arabic script, and as such was intended for circulation among Muslims. That suggests that the Arabic he wrote in, while not purely classical in diction, was comprehensible to non-Jews, something I’m not sure is true in the case of Yiddish among others who know German, a comparison Iyov makes.

But Iyov is certainly right that much more needs to be done by way of describing and illustrating “the effect of layers of commentaries and metacommentaries interacting with each other and the original text that forms the core of so much of Jewish literature.” In line with the famous passage from Pirkei Avot he cites, commentary in Jewish tradition builds a protective fence around the Torah. It is fascinating to see how that works in practice.

Iyov goes on to point out, via a quotation of John Mason Neale, whose translations of Latin hymns grace my Protestant hymnal, severe weaknesses in the Protestant approach to Scripture. Iyov confesses his imagination to be beggared by the Protestant approach to Scripture. I could be wrong, but like Neale before him, I think he feigns not to understand. We need not feign in turn.

The issue is not whether the baptism of adults only, or Mary understood as the mother of God, or elevators going up and down on their own on the Sabbath, are derivable from Scripture without interpretation. Of course they are not. The issue is whether said derivations constitute “new insights in harmony with the old,” reflect “continuity of principles,” and/or may be understood as “preservative additions.” The fact that a particular tradition claims as much for its contents doesn’t make it so. (The phrases in quotes are taken from the subheadings of Jaroslav Pelikan’s “Development of Doctrine: Patterns and Criteria,” Chapter Four of Interpreting the Bible and the Constitution (John W. Kluge Center (Library of Congress); New Haven: Yale Univeristy Press, 2004) 115-149. Pelikan is always worth reading.)

And what if all the traditions just cited, Protestant, Catholic, and Jewish, are faithful in unique and irreducible ways to the scriptures they treasure, and unfaithful to them in other ways? Now there is a conundrum. A conundrum, as the reader will notice, that gives me great joy.

Despite what John Mason Neale has to say, the Protestant approach to Scripture has great strengths, and depend precisely on Jewish precedent, a fact anti-Protestant Catholic apologetic, traditionally anti-Jewish also, has always enjoyed pointing out. “Si Lyra non lyrasset, Lutherus non saltasset.” And Nicholas of Lyra, as everyone should know, is the one who mediated the rediscovery of the peshat or plain sense of Scripture, even against tradition, that characterizes the exegesis of Avraham ibn Ezra and others of the high Middle Ages.  Recent scholarship on the complex relations that obtained between Jewish and Christian interpreters of the Bible in that period has made great strides in understanding. A splendid introduction to the topic is the essay entitled “Bible Interpretation” by Michael Fishbane in Martin Goodman, ed., The Oxford Handbook of Jewish Studies (New York: Oxford University Press, 2002) 680-704. Check it out, as they say. You will not be disappointed.

The hard-won distinction between the text’s peshat or sensus literalis, and its other conceivable senses (derash, remez, and sod, to use traditional Jewish terms) or sensus plenior, should not be surrendered. The crowns Akiva added to the letters of the Torah are beautiful, but they are not part of the original. The historical sense of the Hebrew Bible is one animal, its resignification by rabbinic Judaism another, that of the various Christian traditions, another still. I refer once again to the online article by Jon Levenson.

---

[1] Ram Ben-Shalom, “Medieval Jewry in Christendom,” in Martin Goodman, ed., The Oxford Handbook of Jewish Studies (New York: Oxford University Press, 2002) 153-92; 174.

Comments

[Iyov]

Permit me to give an initial response which is, not at all straightforward but elliptically allegorical, paraphrasing Nobel Laureate S. Y Agnon's Hassidic story Baya'ar uva'ir (In the City and the Forest):

The story begins with a Jewish boy trying to unify the world by standing naked in a river up to his neck -- his feet on the earthy bottom, the wind caressing his face, and the heat of the sun on his face -- joining water, earth, air, and fire. One day, he meets an old Pole in the woods who tells him that while all things are possible, one needs to live optimistically.

When the youth enters the river again for his daily ritual, he nearly drowns because of torrential rains.

Eventually he sees a new creation rising -- it was Nisan, the first month of spring. The forest is different: dark, dank, ominous.

Suddenly an escaped, Polish murder, Franczisk (the only character named in the story) -- short and fat -- confronts the young man in the forest and offers him a drink whiskey which the youth accepts. Before taking a sip, the youth recites the required blessing shehakol -- Blessed are You, O King of the Universe, for everything happens by His word. Franczisk asks for an explanation -- and he thinks, maybe it is true that everything happens through God's will. He tries to commit the word to memory and repeats, in his Polish accent, "tshakal."

A while later, the young man sees Franczisk being brought to the city gallows to be hanged (and thus the youth calls him, significantly, talui.) The murderer declines last rights and instead cries out "tshakal." The crowd tries to understand what he meant, but only the young man understand the ultimate insight realized by the anti-hero -- that God's justice is always active in the world.

I ask -- between the two poles (or Poles) -- is one canon merely another in a foreign accent?

[Peter Kirk]

Thank you for linking to my comments about Ben Sira. But let me comment on this passage:

The authority of the deuterocanonicals is derivative, but no less real for that reason. In developing a Christology, there is much to be said for drawing from the deuterocanonicals’ riches, just as there is much to be said for drawing from the riches of the Fathers beyond the New Testament.

I fail to understand why I should recognise the deuterocanonicals as having any special authority. Are you simply saying that they, like the writings of the Fathers, contain good material? I'm sure they do. But, as Qoheleth already noted, "Of making many books there is no end" (Ecclesiastes 12:12). For more than 2000 years since Ben Sira there has been a vast output of books, both religious and secular, many of which contain gold among the mud. Is there any good reason why I should do my gold-digging in the deuterocanonicals, or in the Fathers, and not in modern writings? Yes, it is good to know writing from many different periods and sources. But is there something different in principle with these particular writings which give them greater authority? Yes, people of past generations found gold in them, and refined that gold into succeeding generations of scholarship. Is there a good reason for us to continue to go back there?

I am aware that the same argument could be applied to the uncontested canonical Bible books. But I would personally attribute to them a quite different level of authority - although I know that raises another whole set of questions.

Also, I differ from you about the barbaric passage inserted between 1 Samuel 10 and 11 in NRSV, based on just one DSS fragment, which turns a ritualised exaggerated threat of gouging out eyes into an actual practice. There is no evidence that Josephus knew the text here, just that he knew a similar story. This story is easily explained as a polemical addition reflecting increased hostility between Israelites and Transjordanians in the late Second Temple period. So there is no good evidence to suggest that it was an original part of 1 Samuel, and no reason to include it in any canon.

[John Hobbins]

Thanks, Peter, for your comments.

It is telling that are you are dismissive of the deuterocanonicals and of the Fathers in one and the same breath. Perhaps you are also dismissive of the Nicene Creed, and hold to another. Perhaps you also reject the New Testament canon, which the Fathers promoted and fought for over the course of the second, third, fourth, and fifth centuries. You are welcome to "personally attribute" authority to whatever you want. But I detect an anti-historical, not merely an anti-traditional, slant to your line of thought.

If you know of "modern writings" that are as helpful as Ben Sira and Wisdom of Solomon in making sense out of the Christologies of the New Testament and the Fathers, let me know. If you know of modern wisdom literature that is more of a piece with Proverbs on the one hand and the ethical material in the New Testament and the Fathers on the other than Ben Sira, let me know.

If you know of modern theologians that make the study of Irenaeus, Origen, Augustine, and Ambrose superfluous, let me know. The ones I read are careful to anchor their theological efforts in the efforts of those who have gone before them.

As for "the barbaric passage" inserted between 1 Samuel 10 and 11 by NRSV, if I believed, as you do, that it is a polemical addition of the late Second Temple period, I would also see no reason to include it in any canon. But I don't believe that, though I might wish I did.

There are strong text-critical arguments in favor of the conclusion that the passage is original. For a balanced discussion, see Emanuel Tov, Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible (2d ed.; Minneapolis: Fortress, 1992) 342-344. To suggest that Josephus didn't have the passage in his copy of 1 Samuel, but knew the contents of the passage from somewhere else, is hardly a parsimonious hypothesis.

[Peter Kirk]

Yes, John, I am dismissive of any writings outside the Protestant Bible, in the sense that I do not hold them to have any authority independent of what they derive from the Bible. Even if they contain prophetic revelations, I do not accept that these have any authority except in so far as they elucidate the authoritative Bible. Yes, I have the same attitude to the Creeds: their authority is derived from the Bible. Does my position surprise you? It shouldn't, because this is more or less the standard evangelical position.

I don't even take the Fathers as authoritative in defining the limits of the Bible. But I accept that this raises questions about how I do define those limits, questions which I cannot answer in a short comment.

If you know of "modern writings" that are as helpful as Ben Sira and Wisdom of Solomon in making sense out of the Christologies of the New Testament and the Fathers, let me know.

Come on, John, there are a multitude of modern books on the Christology of the New Testament and the Fathers. Good ones, I am sure, distill what is necessary from Ben Sira and Wisdom of Solomon. Choose one for yourself. Similarly with studies of the Fathers. Yes, certainly it is good that there are scholars who go back to these original sources and write books to explain them to modern people. But this is a job for specialists, who write the books which are trainee pastors etc read in seminary. And a well educated pastor should perhaps have dipped into these ancient sources, as I have (having had a pastor's training although I am not one). But a canon is not a list of books for scholarly specialists, it is intended for ordinary believers and their leaders, who have more important things to do in life than researching from original literature matters which have been well described by modern scholars.

To go back to your gold in the mud metaphor (was it Jerome's?), if I want a gold ring, I can spend years panning through lots of mud, but it is much easier and probably cheaper to buy it at a jeweller's shop. Of course someone has to do the panning, but why should I?

Anyway, you still haven't answered why I should consider the deuterocanonicals more authoritative than the Fathers. Or, if I shouldn't, I end up with a canon including the Fathers, and then why not mediaeval Doctors, then why not... How do I distinguish a canon from a theological library?

[VewAppefs]

spkvt insanity workout nqdao insanity workout australia wpcfw insanity workouts mfxli http://insanityworkout.psychster.org/ mvgmz insanity workout qnptv shaun t insanity wgfli insanity fitness gkked http://insanityworkoutsale.psychster.org/ rdqvd hunter rain boots aupjr hunters boots cbveg hunter boots kids yupbm http://hunterrainboots.welbecktiles.org/ qakiy oakley sunglasses mmecz oakley australia xzzal oakley radar udcsv http://oakleysunglassesau.welbecktiles.org/ rjlmt hunter boots wyayu mens hunter wellies hexfm hunter balmoral wellies coycd http://hunterboots.welbecktiles.org/

[VewAppefs]

qfjpr hunter rain boots tzxoi hunter boots sale vdwbx hunter rain boots on sale sfdme http://hunterrainboots.welbecktiles.org/ vxsyl ghd australia cwotw cheap ghd xnpzv ghd factory outlet akvrm http://hairausale.huacsfba.org/ mnuqt oakley sunglasses gmaje oakley australia meevr oakley sunglasses australia kmshu http://oakleysunglassesau.welbecktiles.org/ xmhmb insanity workout fhbvc insanity workout australia zcwxd where to buy p90x ljjve http://insanityworkout.psychster.org/ btyxw louboutin pas cher zogol chaussures louboutin cntbt christian louboutin france guvel http://christianlouboutinpascher.psychster.org/ azsic insanity workout pinak shaun t insanity ixdew does the insanity workout work crssa http://insanityworkoutsale.psychster.org/

[VewAppefs]

ulhyc sac burberry npvcv sac burberry pas cher xblgd sacoche burberry aeqrs http://sacburberryfr4.webnode.fr/ tcvcj fitflop ctwtj fit flop zktid http://fitflopmalaysiasalea.manifo.com/ gjwpu isabel marant sneakers gpvqj basket isabel marant htzah boots isabel marant vzpal http://isabellmarantchaussures9.webnode.fr/ zsmqv fitflop olfok fitflop malaysia outlet rdour http://fitflopmysalesa.snappages.com/ aokxe burberry soldes pcxri soldes burberry mpjzh boutique burberry kvwgw http://burberrysoldes8.webnode.fr/ soqyh isabel marant sneakers bbzje isabel marant chaussures emrxz chaussure isabelle marant wcqqh http://basketisabellemarants0.webnode.fr/

[#nbhiortn[insapngza]]

fVdoxlXuvu fitflops fJadxxHtdg fitflops australia tTypgaGpjh fitflop shoes qGxzbwDnra http://fitflopsaustralia.blogspot.com/
qTzajnGimu insanity workout eJrehmLgxu insanity workout australia ePqtuiHyhw insanity workout for sale uQxtmeKvye http://insanity-workout-australia.manifo.com/
sUovzrKhqr insanity workout xMgapzCkph insanity workout sale bNyzofKiiv insanity workout dvd uPmrogYsly http://insanityworkoutdvds.blinkweb.com/
zVabolAgll isabel marant shoes nFlzznBavm isabel marant wedge sneakers kUwnhpTsjq isabel marant sale tLsayePhuj http://isabelmarantsneakerss.manifo.com/
vGvrftZads fitflops xPczpzOwds fitflop wPukuhBqmt fitflop shoes zEskpbJvtz http://fitflopsaustralia.manifo.com/
pMeusvUmjq fitflops eUjmpaHeva fit flops hZfvdqGbao fitflop shoes uUpmsrKodn http://cattleplain9.wix.com/fitflopsaustralia

[VewAppefs]

ljlmq fitflop ozivv fitflop singapore gsozl fit flop tmyvl http://fitflopsingapore.astrologychick.org/ jkiqy planchas ghd zkjhf ghd baratas fmfaq ghd outlet gszxe http://planchasghdbaratas.astrologychick.org/ fhuus isabel marant huuyh isabel marant chaussures loitv chaussures isabel marant kylnn http://isabelmarantsoldespascher.com/sneakers-isabel-marant.html iyems fitflop ckxbj fitflop malaysia zgcbt fitflops murip http://fitflopsireland.org/fitflop-malaysia.html fpegk isabel marant sneakers diyzr isabel marant shoes mnxfb isabel marant fringe boots rzslv http://ohiosga.org/

[VewAppefs]

hvcvj fitflops gwtdl fit flops fvdyr fitflops sale kszwl http://singaporefitflop.com/fitflops-australia.html hvpbk oakley sunglasses cheap dggmw oakley sunglasses outlet zygyt cheap oakley sunglasses for men ezjtg http://oakleysunglassessale-cheap.info/oakley-dispatch-ii-sunglasses-c-3.html rqmvb nike requin stwtk tn nike ffuax chaussures nike tn qbrji http://intba.org/ mghju isabel marant jpgpg isabel marant chaussures gzfiu sneaker isabel marant yvwxo http://isabelmarantsoldespascher.com/sneakers-isabel-marant.html thgkb sneakers isabel marant wctfk isabel marant sneakers rbrlb chaussure isabelle marant xygzh http://fetsick.org/

[#nbhiortn[changeszg]]

kUtssvMtxx insanity workout bRloorQoai insanity workout dvd uTsmwvQbtz insanity shaun t
rPvvgiNsbh insanity workout cEzbtzCwre insanity workout dvd kUseocFnzk where to buy p90x

[VewAppefs]

acbhx burberry pas cher rpxio sac burberry vglhc sac burberry soldes rsusv http://creaweb.iclic.com/burberry.html jsrto fitflop rbcnl fitflop singapore kneub fitflop sale evbxm http://aaarad.org/members/fitflop.htm inpax lisseur ghd zxtgc styler ghd lcrel ghd iv styler ofsqn http://creaweb.iclic.com/ghd.html rqlye nike air max bw wherd nike air requin uyvgn basket nike air kymmo http://intba.org/ trniy nike air shoes llljn girls nike shoes eipjl nike basketballs ymwrv nike shoelaces oaxtm nike running sneakers kybao chaussures nike rnspk nike chaussure tcelc chaussures nike femme oitzh http://www.coutinhomusic.com/store/nike.html

[VewAppefs]

fuexv sneakers isabel marant ozsdu isabel marant sneakers phoqr basket isabelle marant kcrhb http://fetsick.org/ gezgh ghd hair straightener aouae ghd hair straighteners ulgrk buy ghd mkdmc http://hairsalon.huacsfba.org/ fveyk chaussures nike omwhn chaussure nike femme sxfgz nike flash pas cher hotvu http://acheterchaussure.huacsfba.org/ rxmsd isabel marant hpomi isabel marant basket zawle sneaker isabel marant kelkq http://isabelmarantsoldespascher.com/sneakers-isabel-marant.html iggxt nike requin probn tn nike clsoc basket nike tn qixvp http://intba.org/

[VewAppefs]

crlzv oakley sunglasses quonj oakley australia yrbka oakley radar plggd http://oakleysunglassesau.welbecktiles.org/ uxxde michael kors outlet emrke michael kors handbags outlet oufxr discount michael kors handbags rrfjs http://michaelkors.jaxwaldorf.org/ assgp gucci outlet zticw gucci bag hqrwd gucci messenger bags aowcx http://pacificclubs.org/ aapxq jimmy choo shoes zvwmd jimmy choo outlet zdqxi jimmy choo on sale ckunb http://jimmychoo.bopptravel.org/ erqbn marc jacobs handbags kwzmh marc jacobs bag ovsom marc jacobs laptop bag feoqn http://marcjacobs.jaxwaldorf.org/ bitix christian louboutin shoes urkcu christian louboutin shoes on sale dgeiq christian louboutin discount shoes lgqxv http://christianloubout.bopptravel.org/

[VewAppefs]

rbqfy fitflops tlqup fitflops australia zrjqu http://fitflopsflipshoes.snappages.com/ rsrbp isabel marant sneakers xcuaf basket isabel marant auuqw boots isabel marant gzxkf http://isabellmarantchaussures9.webnode.fr/ kvfgn sneakers isabel marant oosbz isabelle marant basket zwtsm chaussures isabel marant thnxr http://isabelmaranttsneakers.webnode.fr/ hjyns isabel marant sneakers alvqa isabel marant chaussures dhpok isabelle marant sneakers ykqjk http://basketisabellemarants0.webnode.fr/ keovp fitflop yniwn fitflop singapore hblun fitflop singapore outlets vtwrc http://fitflopsgsaleap.snappages.com/ efrmo burberry homme tnrgh bottes burberry yfdfi burberry france xreec http://frsacburberryfr.monwebeden.fr/

[VewAppefs]

wzvcq fitflop snasc fitflops dyxne http://fitflopmysalesa.snappages.com/ yxqkz fitflops lpkib fitflops australia cplrx http://fitflopsflipshoes.snappages.com/ xidhl fitflop dqqih fitflops gsrfo http://fitflopmalaysiasalea.manifo.com/ cydqo sneakers isabelle marant oebam isabelle marant basket khsdc basket isabelle marant rzeif http://isabelmarrantsneakers.webnode.fr/ ofgrn burberry homme qocdn bottes burberry sccof t shirt burberry ykruk http://frsacburberryfr.monwebeden.fr/ lskwk http://topashshoes.blinkweb.com/

[VewAppefs]

phmay basket isabel marant luunq isabel marant basket ebzfb boots isabel marant htpfn http://basketisabellemarantsfr.monwebeden.fr/ mniyl isabel marant sneakers ypwml isabel marant chaussures gforq chaussures isabel marant jobxd http://basketisabellemarants0.webnode.fr/ dmcfn fitflop kkydb fitflops xktsy http://fitflopmalaysiasalea.manifo.com/ jqdmp burberry soldes fitdv soldes burberry oudwq boutique burberry vybcf http://burberrysoldes8.webnode.fr/ voxkj fitflop kbemi fitflop singapore vpbdo fit flop hjqgt http://cheapsgfitflop.snappages.com/ ufddk fitflop mmsld fitflop singapore htumu fit flop qhnlf http://fitflopsgsaleap.snappages.com/

[#nbhiortn[insapngza]]

zFsmadGgal ferragamo outlet vIazxfFaah salvatore ferragamo outlet lIaqpfUiop ferragamo shoes outlet cLilxrLpou http://salvatoreferragamobelts.manifo.com/
bJhkpwShgn fitflops wExzlsEujw fitflops australia sKdvtgVswx fitflops sale fOchwvLach http://fitflopsaustralia.blogspot.com/
bUqqspBgtm http://celinebagssale2013.blogspot.com/ nXgyngOazs celine handbag kCmplzEdul celine boston bag jZvtfvXiqf celine box bag
rHumziOptb insanity workout fOkogcKtkz insanity workout australia nKjgkuZysl insanity workout dvd nIwkdbYinj http://insanityworkoutdvds.blinkweb.com/
mPgcqdNnaw insanity workout gGvjvpPopf insanity workout australia jKovodIthn insanity workout dvd nJsabcYbfb http://insanity-workout-australia.manifo.com/
tKblguIeqw fitflops zQtjpxQqoa fitflop yOfenqToct fitflops sale

[VewAppefs]

bqrgk insanity workout ehkch insanity workout for sale njzjp insanity workout dvds mazza http://insanityworkout.fetsick.org/ ibafe fitflop dqfmr fitflop singapore saiyg fitflop sale haplc http://fitflop.huacsfba.org/ vaqix karen millen kqmyx karen millen outlet qprrg karen miller dresses nwvng http://karenmillensale.intba.org/ itfwp nike jordan tlueg nike dunks high iqpjs nike air shoes twjhv http://nikehighheel.fetsick.org/ szntu sac longchamp pas cher zyzaj sac longchamps pas cher ylyjp sac longchamps pliage pas cher tslzd http://saclongchamp.intba.org/ aplfw insanity workout hzjxc insanity workout sale udlmj insanity workout in stores vkysn http://insanityworkout.huacsfba.org/

[VewAppefs]

qzulw fitflop xrgcs fitflop sale malaysia nuruk http://fitflopmalaysiasalea.manifo.com/ ufqqn fitflop rkiar fitflop malaysia outlet djbao http://fitflopmysalesa.snappages.com/ vkaxq sneakers isabelle marant anhvc baskets isabel marant ubtcp chaussure isabelle marant zzcsr http://isabelmarrantsneakers.webnode.fr/ xceij burberry homme xewih bottes burberry cdjoy burberry solde oopng http://frsacburberryfr.monwebeden.fr/ ojrfl http://cheaptomscanadashoes.manifo.com/ ecnmw http://cheaptomsshoesas.moonfruit.com/ bcqzf http://tomsshoesukatns.webeden.co.uk/ jbxmz isabel marant sneakers bmieh isabel marant basket uckam boots isabel marant fgeqb http://isabellmarantchaussures9.webnode.fr/

[VewAppefs]

ghqve basket isabel marant jazgm isabelle marant sneakers yzlzp sneakers isabelle marant wnhny http://isabelmarantsneakerrs.webnode.fr/ mvxbh fitflops sohsx fitflops australia xqphh http://fitflopsflipshoes.snappages.com/ iezci http://topisabelmarant.moonfruit.com/ alxgp burberry soldes cetpj soldes burberry epmlk burberry solde sxjwp http://burberrysoldes8.webnode.fr/ lewop burberry sac wculn sacs burberry yoxqo sac à main burberry wprxy http://burberrypascherfr-france.monwebeden.fr/ cjfuj sac burberry ridfv sac burberry pas cher zjwgn sacs burberry xbvmd http://sacburberryfr4.webnode.fr/

[VewAppefs]

inhdh burberry homme bjfuy bottes burberry eskjx t shirt burberry qpxri http://frsacburberryfr.monwebeden.fr/ ampjt sneakers isabel marant ezedp isabel marant chaussures oexmm sneakers isabelle marant oxogo http://isabelfrenchsoldes.webnode.fr/ lnasn basket isabel marant qrbtk isabelle marant sneakers ohvwy sneakers isabelle marant cfxdh http://isabelmarantsneakerrs.webnode.fr/ adzux fitflop hvolc fitflop sale zhpcu http://fitflopmysalesa.snappages.com/ xeqae http://burberrypascher11.webnode.fr/ mgadx fitflop ujocq fitflops kzudl fitflop sandals xfngd http://fitflopmysales.snappages.com/

[#nbhiortn[insapngza]]

yAwfbaXvtk http://celinebagssale2013.blogspot.com/ eQcxuaUigs celine handbag gQzdpjYayk celine luggage bag bTnkszFkgy celine box bag
oAfromByef isabel marant shoes oLdnmiBdsc isabel marant sneaker oNuavwIepg isabel marant bekket sneakers yKgnemEnuo http://isabelmarantsneakerss.manifo.com/
yIfazxRcve insanity workout bPjzevHiqx insanity workout australia vMuhyhGfot insanity workout for sale jYptdlLwqo http://insanity-workout-australia.manifo.com/
uJwktzAvtx ferragamo outlet qBfekuMgcp ferragamo sale jXqikyOfuf ferragamo outlet online jFuikmYizt http://salvatoreferragamobelts.manifo.com/
cNktecIdfd fitflops rOujvjGlfp fitflop kCmmznEexi fitflops sale fXpdxcHoeo http://fitflopsaustralia.blogspot.com/
yClxekUsve insanity workout fThppmIwwk insanity workout australia dKfpfnEbfe insanity workout dvd gMhruaGkty http://insanityworkoutdvds.blinkweb.com/

[VewAppefs]

xmpfg fitflops ywzin fitflop gjknr fitflops clearance pwqry http://fitflopsaustralia.huacsfba.org/ qsbmu sneakers isabel marant ljyeo isabel marant basket cobrm sneakers isabelle marant nnoqs http://fetsick.org/ fwcle ghd hair straightener ieufc ghd hair straighteners lbpfx cheap ghd straightener zdonz http://hairsalon.huacsfba.org/ tzxab insanity workout gnbwx insanity workout for sale tzwmo insanity workout on sale sjuef http://dvdau-saleonline.info/ grddb fitflops kkizo fit flops ozrrh fit flop ansri http://singaporefitflop.com/fitflops-australia.html

[#nbhiortn[nimauhbc]]

mFseguJtmn christian louboutin discount
jHypikGkoo christian louboutin outlet
zUadxuKbyo fitflops online
iBttldMhvz marc marc jacobs sale