Thinking About Canon (Fourth Update)

A red thread that runs through the discussion thus far anticipates a conclusion of my essay which will appear in the series’ final installment. That is, the notion of canon as a closed list of books, however defensible from a historical point of view, explains exactly nothing. What matters is the role texts play in life and discourse.

Defining a text as canonical if it can be appealed to for the purpose of distinguishing truth from falsehood describes an important function, but is also reductive. A collection of canonical writings, or should I say a primal canon, does more than that. A primal canon’s contents occupy the central place in the religious imagination of those who transmit it. It’s the place one goes to be still and know that the Lord is God. It’s where one tastes the goodness of the Lord. The act of turning to a text and construing it as a lamp unto one’s feet is the central religious fact of both Judaism and Christianity. The more often a text is turned to in this sense, the more canonical it is.

Bob MacDonald is on to this in a big way. He describes the content of the religious imagination the Bible engenders with perfect pitch: God's loving kindness is better than life itself. . . . God is good - this is not to be seen as a biblicist statement . . . [it] is the only verse I know . . . [a] very, very small canon.”  And on that rock, one might say, one might build a church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it.

Doug Chaplin asks a cardinal question: “What difference, if any, does it make to our understanding of canon, if the books selected to be interpreted together and concordantly, start their life in some form of discordance with one another?” My own answer is that the practice of a hermeneutics of difference best fits the shape of the canon. That is, if texts within the canon are in tension with one another (you have heard that it was said, but I say unto you), the fact is best highlighted, not swept under the table.

Since I also believe, ardently and firmly, in the unity of scripture, even if that unity exists only in God, at a level of abstraction beyond the texts per se, I will strive to discern said unity. I’m not sure that is a religious responsibility – consistency, after all, is the hobgoblin of small minds. But it is a theological responsibility.

(Ed.: did you just say that theologians have small minds? You don’t have to say it out loud.)

If texts within the canon occasionally jostle and spar with one another – and they do! – I don’t see why the fact should be denied – and I won’t!

Stephen Cook emphasizes that his main interest is “in the canonical process that produced the Hebrew Bible itself.” As I noted in a previous update, Brevard Childs and James Sanders among Christian interpreters and Michael Fishbane and Marc Zvi Brettler among Jewish interpreters find the concept of canon to be helpful in understanding the how and why of writings and collections of writings now part of the Tanakh/Old Testament. Biblical texts are like onions, to use Shrek’s famous metaphor. The outer layers of many texts allow the whole to be contemporized in the life of succeeding generations. As it is written, “It is not with our fathers that God sealed this covenant, but with us, the living, we who are here today” (Deut 5:3). In the repetition of these words, it is understood, God still speaks.

The book of Deuteronomy in particular vehiculates a contemporization of the past. Bernard Levinson, whose commentary on Deuteronomy in The Jewish Study Bible deserves a careful read, says it well in his comment on Deut 4:9-14:

The revelation at Sinai/Horeb (Exod 19-20) is recalled in order to instruct the present generation who did not experience it. The paired injunctions not to forget the powerful experience of God’s actions and to educate your children, so that the past becomes “present” also to them, represent a prominent aim of Deuteronomy: to overcome the historical distance of the past and to maintain it as a source of identity (4:23, 25; 6:2, 7, 20-25; 8:11; 9:7; 31:13; 32:18). You saw, and the following you stood  (4:10) are highly paradoxical assertions. Neither is literally true: the actual generation of the exodus had died off and been replaced by this new one, one who had experienced none of the events here being recounted (see note to 2:14-15). This paradoxical structure of thought, whereby Moses addresses those who had not witnessed the events as if they had, while insisting that they inculcate the events to posterity, is central to Deuteronomy’s theology of history (5:3-4, 20; 11:7; 29:13-14). This develops further in postbiblical Judaism to the idea that all Jews, past, present, and future, were at Sinai.

Bernard Levinson, “Deuteronomy,” in The Jewish Study Bible (ed. Adele Berlin and Mark Zvi Brettler; New York: Oxford University Press, 2004) ad loc [adapted].

It was Childs, I believe, who first spoke of the “canonical shape” of biblical books. It’s a great insight, even if, as I emphasize, it is often possible to identify more than one canonical shape in which a book has been received in communities of faith past and present.

Jim West notes that “contributions to our understanding of the canon made by Luther and more modern systematic theologians cannot, safely, be ignored.” No argument there. In a previous update, I pointed out that superb interpreters of the Bible have been known to huff and puff about a 2 Peter (Didymus the Blind), a James, or a Revelation (Luther). Despite their reservations, Didymus and Luther go on to selectively deploy the contents of the works they criticized in teaching and polemic.

To take Luther to task for this, as do fundamentalists and arch-Catholics, is pretty dumb of them. The best and most able interpreters of the Bible – and Didymus and Luther qualify - are confident enough to challenge and critique individual parts thereof precisely because they are absolutely committed to the truth the Bible expresses globally insofar as they understand it.

But the force of a canon should not be underestimated. As I noted before, not even an interpreter of the stature and brilliance of Luther could overcome it. The following dictum applies to all:

The Bible, taken with all its diverse meanings, demands of its reader the range of vision which can be defined as the Christian vision. [emphasis mine]

Sean McEvenue, “The Old Testament, Scripture or Theology?” Interpretation 25 (1981) 229-242; 242.

As far as Barth and Brunner are concerned, Brunner’s Sixth Counter-Thesis to Barth states that the Scriptures not only become the Word of God, they are the Word of God. I’m with Brunner on this one.

Duane Smith examines the concept of canon/authority from the points of view of epistemology and psychology. He concludes:

As my favorite theologian once said,

Loyalty to petrified opinion never broke a chain or freed a human soul in this world - and never will. [Mark Twain, Consistency speech, 1887]

How true.

I thank Claude Mariottini for pointing his readers in the direction of this discussion.

Comments

[Doug Chaplin]

I think Emerson said it was a "foolish" consistency.
Does that lead to an irregular verb:
I am coherent
You are foolishly consistent
He/she is small-minded

[#nbhiortn[changeszg]]

xMtrgdBktu insanity workout sNbjmgQmkd insanity workout australia hYmwkgVrfs cheap insanity dvds
zCkcsuYsck insanity workout lVczuxMbhh insanity workout dvd tTvlfrInzl insanity workout online

[#nbhiortn[changeszg]]

dNghrjJmgz insanity workout uXbwizRtot insanity workout dvd aStuhmFliq insanity workout dvds
fOskdjMlgx insanity workout cJssvtLpgr insanity workout for sale yPuwneItdc insanity workout dvd

[VewAppefs]

vimlj fitflop jzgyp fitflop malaysia icdae fit flop bcmcs http://fitflopsireland.org/fitflop-malaysia.html ikcey ghd hair straightener dtqav ghd straightener lemra ghd online cjdgh http://hairsalon.huacsfba.org/ rgzqw nike requin tpqdy tn nike dgqjs requin tn nike vqnfv http://intba.org/ gbjtc fitflop qwbwx fitflop malaysia jodiu fitflop sale dereg http://fitflopmalaysia.astrologychick.org/ izzot fitflops qxafk fitflops australia mszwx fitflop shoes edtvv http://singaporefitflop.com/fitflops-australia.html

[VewAppefs]

vapky burberry outlet pixge burberry bag mcpfi burberry outlets ohrrl http://www.coutinhomusic.com/store/burberry.html wrein nike air max bw dxnyk nike airmax vdmpa nike aire jordan vhovx http://intba.org/ cjehu fitflop sfhkk fitflop singapore decte fit flop ddytq http://aaarad.org/members/fitflop.htm fsilp ghd australia zlelj ghd hair straighteners jdklw ghd outlet yvjtn http://www.coutinhomusic.com/store/ghd.html jyvyh tiffany uk xfapn tiffany jewellery uk crprm tiffany uk sale rifsg http://www.ghi.org.uk/tiffanyuk.asp akzma lisseur ghd ykwfu styler ghd iwamx ghd gold max styler xmqoz http://creaweb.iclic.com/ghd.html

[#nbhiortn[insapngza]]

jMatvvSpca fitflops iTsgzzExba fitflops australia kZdkupYjwc fitflops sale hBtjqqEliy http://fitflopsaustralia.blogspot.com/
mZmectBosp fitflops yEpwziPsew fitflop sAgbzgVhqe fitflop shoes tRwiyiVfcp http://fitflopsale.snack.ws/
pMuiqqVllm fitflops fVqvyyPcvk fitflops australia iMfovuYgki fitflops sale rOymctQctd http://cattleplain9.wix.com/fitflopsaustralia
oIfkeuGtfy insanity workout jMkpotEddg insanity workout australia tWixfpBqfw insanity workout dvd zGsimfLrhh http://insanity-workout-australia.manifo.com/
nWqnzhOxev ferragamo outlet eUnzegUdva salvatore ferragamo outlet aJzdtiBgdr ferragamo outlet online dYmfeoOobv http://salvatoreferragamobelts.manifo.com/
iZtmugSylj isabel marant shoes vBpiinAhhz isabel marant wedge sneakers fFmsrtSwxl isabel marant bekket sneakers hAjbktAoev http://isabelmarantsneakerss.manifo.com/

[#nbhiortn[changeszg]]

cEbahhGvlf insanity workout bJemufAkoe insanity workout for sale xHclclWusz insanity workout in stores
sRrhrdMyep insanity workout gXtdwaRhqm insanity workout for sale zZwdugTxyz insanity fitness

[VewAppefs]

lwexb hunter rain boots nmccr hunter rain boots sale iltfh hunter boot socks vozkq http://hunterrainboots.welbecktiles.org/ igcig oakley sunglasses cdshj oakley australia ilpvu oakley holbrook misbk http://oakleysunglassesau.welbecktiles.org/ uaohr insanity workout kuyhh insanity workout dvd tdoqe insanity workout on sale qjnpp http://insanityworkout.psychster.org/ epgfp insanity workout romoa insanity workout online iaiec insanity beachbody hhsnh http://insanityworkoutsale.psychster.org/ skccs hunter wellies sale ralut mens hunter wellies enmel hunter gloss wellies gaeez http://hunterboots.welbecktiles.org/

[VewAppefs]

bobom ghd hair straightener ftdyl ghd straighteners uifpy cheap ghd hair straightener wawym http://hairsalon.huacsfba.org/ jeofm fitflops okmtj fitflop bxeyw fitflop australia lonea http://singaporefitflop.com/fitflops-australia.html sgkxv chaussures nike yiymd chaussure nike femme yuduk nike chaussure femme xduqx http://acheterchaussure.huacsfba.org/ nuywn isabel marant sneakers fpjpb isabel marant dicker boots zhzqr isabel marant sneakers sale aysur http://isabelmarantsneakers.asia/isabel-marant-sneakers.html kxdlj fitflop yvmbh fitflop malaysia kuodq fitflop sale malaysia dqrpo http://fitflopmalaysia.astrologychick.org/

[VewAppefs]

cgpst fitflop rezsq fitflop malaysia pltdm fitflop malaysia store qpawx http://fitflopmalaysia.astrologychick.org/ amplm nike requin wmzoj tn nike vjlix nike requin tn exfuc http://intba.org/ wwkzm fitflop eakux fitflop singapore ofnax fitflops sale gkvbx http://fitflopsingapore.astrologychick.org/ ctvlp oakley sunglasses cheap kaiik cheap oakley ekozp oakley cheap wmnsj http://oakleysunglassessale-cheap.info/oakley-split-jacket-sunglasses-c-24.html ypwtb isabel marant sfiaj sneakers isabel marant xtboa sneakers isabelle marant mzmgl http://isabelmarantsoldespascher.com/sneakers-isabel-marant.html

[VewAppefs]

hpdmi http://burberrypascher11.webnode.fr/ nfgjy fitflop icjyn fitflop malaysia bxjuj fitflop sale rmniy http://fitflopmysales.snappages.com/ fjvuu http://cheaptomscanadashoes.manifo.com/ hwbes http://cheaptomsshoesas.moonfruit.com/ opuug http://tomsshoesukatns.webeden.co.uk/ hvxfa isabel marant sneakers tzlhz isabel marant basket nurbt boots isabel marant msuyr http://isabellmarantchaussures9.webnode.fr/ zeyjz fitflops aujzq fitflops australia qmfuj http://fitflopsflipshoes.snappages.com/ mqwig burberry soldes ykdxa soldes burberry vbsnt burberry solde shnuh http://burberrysoldes8.webnode.fr/

[VewAppefs]

jwqbq insanity workout jxrzq insanity workout sale zafnp cheap insanity dvds rpdcp http://insanityworkout.psychster.org/ dzudo gucci outlet tqbpn gucci bag vpdgc gucci factory outlet hiljr http://pacificclubs.org/ gkifz michael kors outlet wzklx michael kors factory outlet ayhpa michael kors outlet bags nmyuz http://michaelkors.jaxwaldorf.org/ zywhs insanity workout crdob insanity workout online icelc insanity beachbody vqeln http://insanityworkoutsale.psychster.org/ snuma louboutin pas cher alcch chaussure louboutin pas cher zdvwr louboutins pas cher twbht http://christianlouboutinpascher.psychster.org/ kpghm marc jacobs handbags umfcu marc by marc jacobs handbags rougb marc jacobs baby bag glxtg http://marcjacobs.jaxwaldorf.org/

[VewAppefs]

yeqnv sac burberry qywho sac burberry pas cher vuodw sacs burberry msrfx http://sacburberryfr4.webnode.fr/ obpxb basket isabel marant ohcgg isabel marant basket isflx chaussures isabel marant geust http://isabelmarantsneakerrs.webnode.fr/ oegau sneakers isabel marant dvuxm baskets isabel marant tnajr chaussure isabelle marant ypdff http://isabelmaranttsneakers.webnode.fr/ axqtv burberry homme qnyym bottes burberry dklbl trench burberry femme vnkac http://frsacburberryfr.monwebeden.fr/ qhwvf sneakers isabelle marant xtabh baskets isabel marant abzly chaussures isabel marant nukut http://isabelmarrantsneakers.webnode.fr/ boieg fitflops hcene fitflops australia bmpwy http://fitflopsflipshoes.snappages.com/

[VewAppefs]

ctxhm fitflop tknki fitflops twlij fitflop sale ocoey http://fitflopmysales.snappages.com/ lrmap fitflop bjumd fitflops alhtv fitflop singapore outlets fsggr http://cheapsgfitflop.snappages.com/ myxrn http://cheaptomscanadashoes.manifo.com/ wrnzi http://cheaptomsshoesas.moonfruit.com/ mdkoe http://tomsshoesukatns.webeden.co.uk/ luphw fitflop ezhav fitflops ezcvc fit flop singapore iywep http://fitflopsgsaleap.snappages.com/ bmbvm burberry sac shqxp burberry solde vsskb sac à main burberry tcznm http://burberrypascherfr-france.monwebeden.fr/ pixxy sneakers isabel marant yjbfd isabel marant chaussures cmgyv sneakers isabelle marant dphal http://isabelfrenchsoldes.webnode.fr/

[#nbhiortn[insapngza]]

yFzmalGmhi fitflops kFqrxqCctl fitflop cKnxjmSpft fitflops sale wJinrnOojf http://fitflopsaustralia.manifo.com/
vRgrbvLsgn fitflops yIntonEmsc fit flops uDmtcaWeml fitflops sale
eIoqilHggy fitflops vDfnadYprk fit flops kHlxvfGjif fitflop shoes kVjcakJfwy http://fitflopsaustralia.blogspot.com/
vIxzxdVcap fitflops pNsytzZzeq fitflops australia kDbjuaMezf fitflops sale rGxoctLgfe http://cattleplain9.wix.com/fitflopsaustralia
dRnmgnNasj fitflops eDockmLmzu fitflops sale vPymfsQekv fitflops on sale jJpkqcOwwy http://fitflopsale.snack.ws/
dGpghzXdvp insanity workout uOiwrjFqyg insanity workout australia oVbrzcCiqk insanity workout dvd jQtytfIdmh http://insanity-workout-australia.manifo.com/

[VewAppefs]

rjakf sneakers isabel marant bdtej isabelle marant basket nrgrw chaussures isabel marant tluph http://isabelmaranttsneakers.webnode.fr/ dieyu fitflop wysru fitflops fqvgf fitflops sale eonsx http://fitflopsgsaleap.snappages.com/ afoeq http://insanityworkout-sale.webspawner.com/ tlkxr burberry homme spake bottes burberry fohqa t shirt burberry jwsrn http://frsacburberryfr.monwebeden.fr/ gszjo basket isabel marant fciay isabel marant basket yoogd sneakers isabelle marant tjkkb http://isabelmarantsneakerrs.webnode.fr/ uvnlf fitflop akoys fitflops fsfqv flip flop sandals jlctb http://cheapsgfitflop.snappages.com/

[#nbhiortn[changeszg]]

rRgxoxIxmn insanity workout lZqtsgQqjs insanity workout dvd uWttfqTlop insanity workouts
vNlalwWqdx insanity workout kXjxwyNvux insanity workout sale rVfcysZoiq insanity fitness

[VewAppefs]

emdcc ghd hair straightener iprjp ghd hair straighteners tsxdw ghd straightener cheap gslkt http://hairsalon.huacsfba.org/ gvykv insanity workout ukhoo insanity workout sale keysx insanity workouts kxcch http://dvdau-saleonline.info/ ukrdy oakley sunglasses cheap vgber cheap oakley enkix oakley sunglasses clearance ccuvt http://oakleysunglassessale-cheap.info/oakley-frogskins-sunglasses-c-8.html crnkr nike requin jsfss tn nike gizlq requin tn nike wvjma http://intba.org/ jssdg fitflop jubgx fitflop malaysia qqwyp fitflop sale malaysia imlki http://fitflopsireland.org/fitflop-malaysia.html

[#nbhiortn[insapngza]]

hOwcasSdzj fitflops sEdxyzHdvv fit flops uJdzajNpxv fitflop shoes cKqawkWkji http://fitflopsaustralia.blogspot.com/
yThqsgUkhy sneakers isabel marant qRsiudFyfl basket isabelle marant nUnrfkMfgi chaussures isabel marant
bSxronJghq insanity workout gRhlylMdwo insanity workout sale aZbzdvRagi insanity workout for sale bAsbcdZpkm http://insanity-workout-australia.manifo.com/
uPgwseSmnl insanity workout eWbbrdKluh insanity workout australia fBvdpbAxmp insanity workout dvd cRnhuvMlcr http://insanityworkoutdvds.blinkweb.com/
jByjzjKqul fitflops iSmugiQgub fitflops australia wMzjucQqkm fitflops sale mJibakUcwd http://fitflopsaustralia.manifo.com/
uVapirXuas isabel marant shoes mBvnqqXlet isabel marant sneaker qJiuinIymg isabel marant sale cYmyrnYgtx http://isabelmarantsneakerss.manifo.com/

[#nbhiortn[insapngza]]

rMlwrxOlkd ferragamo outlet sKkfjfDuyt salvatore ferragamo outlet uDfbjsAvtu ferragamo outlet online zDdvxtThpe http://salvatoreferragamobelts.manifo.com/
fHhtppYtle insanity workout qLomlbNwgw insanity workout sale kXstwlZpwd insanity workout for sale jWxsawPmoc http://insanityworkoutdvds.blinkweb.com/
eHxquxGxan fitflops gDjebaLkra fitflop cNeollIrfo fitflops on sale kFojorPajb http://fitflopsale.snack.ws/
nQbpmwNqvx insanity workout tAfiusPdok insanity workout sale iAcntnTlcn insanity workout dvd dSpgdlWdov http://insanity-workout-australia.manifo.com/
yIdoctEcnq fitflops gFfpcyWfxa fitflops australia zMukmwIhhq fitflops sale sQixeaVxqp http://cattleplain9.wix.com/fitflopsaustralia
cYxienBthr fitflops tAaerxGrfl fit flops sKfyqtOext fitflops sale fPmszgWqbz http://fitflopsaustralia.manifo.com/

[casquette supreme]

Rarely lower, regardless of whether may pathetic, for those who never know who may be removal obsessed about all your be happy. casquette supreme http://d99.fr/

[VewAppefs]

ynlcn basket isabel marant iizbt baskets isabel marant mmlan boots isabel marant dvbgm http://basketisabellemarantsfr.monwebeden.fr/ bbapa fitflops uqmhy fitflops sale drjog http://fitflopsflipshoes.snappages.com/ ahlzf fitflop zzbex fitflop sale malaysia nhohu http://fitflopmysalesa.snappages.com/ pymhv sac burberry trkfq sac burberry pas cher ctdfi sacoche burberry zunrh http://sacburberryfr4.webnode.fr/ xxvpw http://cheaptomscanadashoes.manifo.com/ zzbsb http://cheaptomsshoesas.moonfruit.com/ qchlm http://tomsshoesukatns.webeden.co.uk/ vzzdt fitflop yuily fitflops eigqo fit flops yawra http://fitflopsgsaleap.snappages.com/

[VewAppefs]

rezvh fitflop gzdyh fitflop malaysia vddmy fitflop malaysia online ufkas http://fitflop.intba.org/ hfdne fitflops ytrrm fitflop dbrsl fitflops clearance pdlvx http://fitflops.huacsfba.org/ xlxdz toms shoes sale xmyad toms shoes on sale hksgg toms shoe sale vcrdv http://tomshoes.ohiosga.org/ tucaq nike heels ivpqk nike jordan shoes fwcys nike dunk heels vbbek http://nikehighheel.fetsick.org/ huquu sac longchamp pliage ymyeo sac longchamp solde xcyai sacs longchamps soldes swelj http://saclongchamp.fetsick.org/ aeoub nike high tops juetw nike dunk high llnde high tops nike fncej http://nikehighheel.ohiosga.org/

[#nbhiortn[changeszg]]

lDxkodVavp insanity workout vCizzqBtgd insanity workout sale oLrdpbExac p90x vs insanity
nUbnuyWftm insanity workout fLyltcMpdj insanity workout australia xLupafJyzg p90x vs insanity

[VewAppefs]

lrkdu sac burberry pgfcc sac burberry pas cher dlczr sacs burberry ttwrh http://sacburberryfr4.webnode.fr/ pyljd fitflop nsclf fitflops dkkrm http://fitflopmalaysiasalea.manifo.com/ pixho burberry soldes krhvm soldes burberry ukqhz boutique burberry hsask http://burberrysoldes8.webnode.fr/ oryqb fitflop fabrb fitflops gfjti fitflops sale ulvti http://fitflopsgsaleap.snappages.com/ lnaat http://cheaptomscanadashoes.manifo.com/ fcbrf http://cheaptomsshoesas.moonfruit.com/ pfdyh http://tomsshoesukatns.webeden.co.uk/ sheuh fitflops tchnd fitflop sale ksehu http://fitflopsflipshoes.snappages.com/

[VewAppefs]

erwnj fitflops nweoa fitflops australia hokhj http://fitflopsflipshoes.snappages.com/ sawnt burberry soldes kvyuw soldes burberry uwztz burberry solde bgiyg http://burberrysoldes8.webnode.fr/ ilgav basket isabel marant wtiiy isabelle marant sneakers hwuin sneakers isabelle marant jytlz http://isabelmarantsneakerrs.webnode.fr/ msgig sneakers isabelle marant spdoo sneakers isabel marant yajod basket isabelle marant maaez http://isabelmarrantsneakers.webnode.fr/ knnxd sac burberry zpkxd sac burberry pas cher qnirs sacs burberry fbcmb http://sacburberryfr4.webnode.fr/ ungpf sneakers isabel marant ihxqn isabel marant chaussures hxxsm chaussures isabel marant eoyro http://isabelmaranttsneakers.webnode.fr/

[VewAppefs]

trvrv insanity workout lobjr insanity workout dvd nlwil where to buy p90x tacop http://insanityworkout.huacsfba.org/ edpci toms shoes sale dumnb toms shoes on sale cboog buy toms shoes uioss http://tomshoes.ohiosga.org/ qvxrl karen millen xwgzz karen millen outlet kimwy karen miller dresses awtyj http://karenmillensale.intba.org/ wnoxf fitflop xrxdi fitflop singapore zpyuy fitflop sale fssgf http://fitflop.huacsfba.org/ nkwqe fitflops inwkc fitflop australia njdzb fitflops australia online vqzod http://fitflops.huacsfba.org/ ffgyh nike high tops tsmpf nike hightops cutxv nike vandal high dbhve http://nikehighheel.ohiosga.org/

[#nbhiortn[wonimahg]]

kUzelxHwal marc jacobs outlet
bSncxgZcjp fitflops australia
qPqejwZvsm christian louboutin discount

[#nbhiortn[changeszg]]

vKdugdUbgr insanity workout lKeockKfyw insanity workout dvd hFpgysVuew insanity fitness
bJyjgwRfcl insanity workout eZvkkoQmzr insanity workout australia zPxkgaCfrn insanity 60 day workout

[#nbhiortn[wonimahg]]

lLhboiFlyk christian louboutin sale
yOqjfjOcna marc jacobs handbags outlet
iQcqehVzog marc marc jacobs sale

[#nbhiortn[wonimahg]]

zOumtkXltd marc jacobs handbags outlet
fUgqykDoox christian louboutin sneakers
fOegcbPhyf michael kors bag