Reflections of a Biblical Literalist on Unfulfilled Prophecy (Round Two)

Avery Archer has responded to my response to his piece entitled The Philosopher vs. the Biblical Fundamentalist. The conversation is worth continuing because it illuminates issues of interpretation which come up again and again.

For example, it is typical in Judaism and in Christianity for a first text to be appropriated in a second text. The first text may be embedded in the Tanakh/Old Testament; the second, in a layer of rabbinic or Christian tradition. Later texts abstract elements of earlier ones and utilize them in the construction of a synthesis. Overall content and emphasis change, sometimes radically. Whoever supposes that the content and emphases of the later text are, by definition, implicit in the earlier, misunderstands the process. Whoever points out that content and emphases are dissimilar, and opines that said fact proves the inauthentic nature of the appropriation, also misunderstands the process. Later texts express a metanarrative whose fixed points lie outside of the earlier texts they appropriate. Later texts attempt to show that these fixed points are capable of coordination with fixed points in earlier texts. Discerned one-to-one correspondence (“this is that”) is not the same thing as identity.

To be sure, it requires a historical frame of mind to make the distinction between correspondence and identity. Interpreters ancient and modern make the distinction when it serves their purposes, which is not often, and otherwise elide it. But the interpreter interested in the sense a text had once upon a time, in its original or in a subsequent historical context, must protect the otherness of the text from premature conflation with an extraneous metanarrative. The philosopher, I assume, is bound by an identical hermeneutical deontology.

As I stated in my previous reply, if a biblical literalist is someone who "interprets the Bible at face value unless otherwise clearly indicated" (Avery's definition), then I am one. Said definition is interesting, though of course the epithet "literalist" is more often applied to the one who construes another’s words in an over-literal or simplistic manner. In my view, that is what Avery continues to do. This time around, he constructs the following syllogism:

(A) The members of the Holy Trinity are infallible

(B) Jesus made a mistake, and therefore is not infallible

(C) Jesus is not a member of the Holy Trinity

Archer understands (A) to be a “simple” restatement of the Christian doctrine of divine omniscience. I beg to differ. (A) is not simple but simplistic. It requires qualification. The first Christians made a distinction between God the Son who, in an act of self-emptying (kenosis), became like us “in everything but sin” between birth and death on a cross; and that same person who, before birth and after God raised him from the dead, fully participates in divine omniscience. As Jesus is reported to have said, “No one knows about that day or hour, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father” (Matthew 24:36).

This verse might even be understood to imply that the Son, irrespective of incarnation, does not fully participate in divine omniscience. A discussion of that would be interesting in its own right, but would take us far afield. An examination of early tradition, in particular, the diverse christologies of Justin Martyr, Irenaeus, Origen, and Clement of Alexandria, might prove helpful. My sense is that Archer is unaware of the riches of the formative period of christological thinking. Perhaps he has also failed to read a nuanced account of the christologies of the New Testament. That of Leonhard Goppelt entitled Theology of the New Testament: The Variety and Unity of the Apostolic Witness to Christ might be recommended. Instead of a three-step historical process (christologies of the New Testament; christologies of subsequent centuries; christology as defined in the creeds), he judges the New Testament against the standard of fully developed christology of three centuries later. In the process, he makes the Society for Creative Anachronism look conservative.

[Ed.: The folk Avery refers to as “biblical fundamentalists” interpret a-historically all the time. Why can’t Avery? Archer is smarter than that. I hold him to a higher standard.]

It’s time to return to the subject matter at hand: unfulfilled prophecy. Jesus is reported to have expected the prophecies of Daniel to be fulfilled in the lifetime of his hearers. Said prophecies include the prediction of a definitive victory of Israel over its enemies, as well as, according to Jesus, a judgment day in which individuals will be judged for what they did or did not do. In point of fact, said prophecies went unfulfilled, both then and since.

To say so is not “curious,” as Archer has it, but a statement of the obvious. Matthew 24:36, Acts 1:6-7 (cited in my earlier post), and, at greater length, 2 Peter 3:1-9, handle the issue of postponed fulfillment in a variety of ways. Furthermore, as I pointed out in my previous post, examples of unfulfilled prophecy in the Bible abound. It is not possible for Jewish interpreters to say, “The issue is unimportant in my tradition.” Nor is it possible for Christian interpreters to say, “The issue relates to the Old Testament, not the New.”

In Avery’s response to mine, he ups the ante, and I’m ready to comply. If a biblical fundamentalist is someone who “refus[es] to pick and choose which parts of the Bible [he/she] takes to be authoritative, in the manner that many liberal Christians do” (Avery’s definition), then I am a biblical fundamentalist. Give me that old-time religion. I am just as sick and tired of the “à la carte” approach to scripture as is Avery.

I would go one step further: if the formulation of a systematic theologian stands in contradiction to the plain witness of scripture, I side with the latter. I don’t care how respected said theologian is, or how many theological popes, ancient or modern, attest to the correctness of the systematization. As far as I’m concerned, the primacy of scripture still obtains.

Furthermore, I don’t think we should expect the various writings of the Old and New Testaments to give us a single harmonizable picture of “the end times” or any other point of doctrine. A variety of pictures, talking points, and whatnot are presented. Each conveys a truth which is lost if amalgamated with the others according to a heterological scheme.

Texts as various as Isa 2:2-5; Isa 65:17-66:24; Ezek 38-39; the prophecies of Daniel; Matt 25:31-46; Luke 16:19-31; 1 Thes 4:13-5:3; and Rev 19:11-22:7, for example, are not reducible to one another. Modern-day attempts to discern instances in which they illuminate the structure of contemporary events or anticipate the future follow interpretive procedures, it seems to me, that are as old as the texts themselves. Bring it on. On the other hand, to the extent that they rely on a harmonization of disparate elements arbitrarily lifted from some texts and not others, not on the raw witness of the texts themselves, said attempts are bound to mislead.

[Ed.: Hey, you promised that you would write with both Jews and Christians in mind. Are not Jews little more than bemused bystanders in this debate? Does the name Menahem Mendel Schneerson mean nothing to you? Messianic eschatology is alive and well in Judaism today. It draws on pre-existing traditions and interpretive procedures no less than contemporary Christian eschatology.]

I would suggest that a dose of humility is in order. In lieu of a unified theory of everything, it is necessary, this side of the kingdom, to hold to plural, partial, and, strictly speaking, irreconcilable construals of eschatology and other points of theological doctrine. I am happy to cheer wannabe theological Einsteins on, but I don’t expect them to achieve in theology what Einstein did not in physics.

Too often, it has been assumed that the epistemology of theology has little or nothing in common with the epistemology of other sciences. Archer, in my view, falls headlong into this trap. He wants to hold the Bible to standards of conceptual rigor which, if applied to modern physics, with its “complementary” wave and particle theories of matter and energy, its quarks, gluons, and what have you, would reduce even the great lectures of Richard Feynman to a morass of contradictions. The consistency which Archer looks for, and does not find, is the hobgoblin of small minds.

There are no special hermeneutics that apply to scripture alone, and there is no special epistemology that applies to knowledge of God and no other kind of knowledge. If one interprets the writings of the Bible singly, the methods of interpretation to apply are the same as those that apply to individual writings more generally. If one interprets the writings of the Bible as components of the larger corpus of which they are now a part, the methods of interpretation to apply are the same as those that apply in the case of corpora of writings such as constitutions in conjunction with case law. Jaroslav Pelikan recently wrote a book about the hermeneutical commonalities (Interpreting the Bible and the Constitution [Yale University Press, 2004]).

I could be wrong, but Archer comes across as someone who overdosed a while back on apologists like Josh McDowell, and gave up on Christianity in the process. If so, that is a tribute to Archer. The arrogance of apologists like McDowell is appalling. The Bible is full of questions as well as answers. The questions are just as canonical as the answers. McDowell, if memory serves, has only answers. The people Archer should be reading are George Mavrodes, Keith Yandell, Alvin Plantinga, and Nicholas Wolterstorff.

Archer is right to apply the rules of logic to theories of all kinds. Those of subatomic physics and those of the “end times” are equally game. He will find grist for his mill in both cases. My thesis is this: if he explored the logic of both religious and scientific theories, he would discover how alike their logics are. It also matters little whether the theory of the end times Archer puts under the microscope is that of a Hal Lindsey or that of an Al Gore. Both, he would discover, throw caution to the wind and engage in wanton and thinly substantiated speculation. Both, it is not difficult to predict, will be shown to have barked up the wrong tree by subsequent facts.[1]

But Archer should not apply the rules of symbolic logic to individual propositions contained in the occasional writings of non-systematic thinkers. Or if he does so, he needs to cut said thinkers a bit more slack than he seems inclined to do.

I’ve said my peace for the moment. Before I hang up my skates, I wish to rectify something I wrote in my previous post. I suggested there that the prophetic test of Deut 18:20 is not very helpful. Archer suggests I impugn Deut 18:20 by so declaring. He has a point. I don’t think the test is meant to be as broadly applied as Archer wants, but I admit the test is useful in some circumstances. A comment on Deut 18:20 by Jeffrey Tigay is apropos:

“The Bible records two cases in which proceedings were initiated, possibly on the basis of this law, against prophets accused of falsely attributing their prophecies to God; in both cases they were exonerated. When Micaiah son of Imlah prophesied that Ahab would fall in battle, Ahab had him taken into custody, assuming – wrongly – that he would return from battle safely and Micaiah’s claim to divine authority would be proven false (1 Kings 22:17-28). Jeremiah was tried for false prophecy when he foretold the destruction of Jerusalem. His accusers called for the death penalty, but he was exonerated on the grounds that he truly spoke in the name of the Lord (Jer. 26).”[2]

More to the point, appeal to the precedent of the prophet Micah made it dubious to treat Jeremiah in a way Micah had not been treated (see my previous post). Later on, we read that Jeremiah was imprisoned but not killed, a holding action, perhaps, until it became clear whether or not his prophecy of the destruction of Jerusalem came true. It did.

Jeremiah and Jesus are among the prophets because a grave prediction both made came to pass: the destruction of the center of the universe as they and their fellow religionists understood it. That is what Jerusalem is for the faith of Israel: the ordained intersection of the divine and human planes; the heiress of God’s most wonderful promises. It was hardly a minor detail that they predicted her destruction. Even if other predictions they made went unfulfilled, or were fulfilled later in circumstances they did not foretell, or await fulfillment to this day, their title to have spoken the truth in this instance cannot be taken away.

The amount of garbage that has been written about prophecy rivals the bulk of Mt. Everest. I assume that Archer’s mind was poisoned by contact with it. Strong antidotes to pulp apologetic include the following essays by Martin Buber: “Plato and Isaiah,” and “False Prophets,” pp. 103-112 and 113-118, respectively, in idem, Israel and the World: Essays in a Time of Crisis (2d ed.; New York: Schocken Books, 1963 [1948]).

---

[1] The books of both, it also not difficult to predict, will outsell by several orders of magnitude those written by others who patiently poke holes in their lines of argument. Should a reversal occur, I promise to switch from a pre-mil to an in-mil position.

[2] Jeffrey H. Tigay, Deuteronomy (The JPS Torah Commentary; Philadelphia: The Jewish Publication Society, 1996) 177.

Comments

[Shawn F.]

Quite enjoyed this discussion between you both. A good example of respectful dialogue and I come away feeling I learned something.

[terri]

I just read that passage the other day...the one in Deuteronomy. What crossed my mind was that it seems to apply to a prophecy with an immediate time frame in which the prophet could be judged.

I always wondered how they viewed prophets who prophesied about things that didn't happen for hundreds of years, such as Isaiah. Was he regarded as a true prophet even though he was long dead before most of his prophecies came to pass?

[JohnFH]

Good questions, Terri. It could be that the prophecies you are thinking of had a multiple fulfillment. That is, they were fulfilled in one way in the prophet's lifetime, and in another way later.

Here's an example. Micah, a 8th cent BCE contemporary of Isaiah, prophesied that Zion would be plowed as a field, and Jerusalem would become a heap of ruins (Micah 3:7). Given all the ways in which Jerusalem of Micah's day disregarded the will of God as Micah understood it, it made sense to predict as Micah did. But God is sovereign and mitigated the destruction, in line with Isaiah's predictions (cf. Isa 6 and 37, for example; destruction, yes, but Zion is saved in extremis). Still, the gist of the predictions of doom made by Micah came true in his lifetime, and that insured that they were collected and passed on to future generations.

Jeremiah, more than a century later, quotes Micah's prediction (even if it had not come true to the letter) in defense of his own similar prediction (Jer 26:18). Not long thereafter, Jeremiah and Micah's prediction came true, and in spades.

Prophecy and history relate to one another in far from completely predictable ways. The guidelines laid down in Deuteronomy were helpful, but only up to a point. The trouble was, God has a habit of mitigating punishment, which is the subtext behind the plot of the book of Jonah. Jonah knew about this divine habit and so he didn't want to go to Nineveh and preach repentance, for fear that God would relent and not deal out the punishment Nineveh the city richly deserved. Jonah was not wrong about that.

Another example. A prophecy like Micah 5:1 may well have been understood to have found fulfillment in, say, the reign of King Josiah, before being interpreted in reference to the hope for a Messiah King that grew and grew as time passed. Its application to Jesus is well-known and makes perfect sense within the larger narrative Christians discerned to be realized in the one who was born in Bethlehem.

[Ben Smith]

Hi John,

This is still helpful, but I'm wondering what you make of the idea of Pauls' or Jesus' 'interim ethics'? Does the fact that they were expecting an imminent end affect the way we see, for instance, Paul's ambivalence towards marriage?

[JohnFH]

I think so, though it is easy to reformulate things such that it is still appropriate for Christians to seek the gift of celibacy even if the novissima are not on the immediate horizon.

[Ben Smith]

That's true. What about political matters, as in obeying the authorities on Romans 13?

[JohnFH]

I wouldn't want to quote Romans 13 in isolation, without also quoting Revelation 13.

Both passages are shaped by a Maranantha vision of the world, if you will, a vision worth maintaining, without however pretending to know when and in what sense the prayer will be answered in our generation.

[#nbhiortn[changeszg]]

oBqxtoVxlo insanity workout vWqrpcWtcl insanity workout australia qCjnpiYsaa insanity workout on sale
iXeuxiDeng celine luggage tote gCqqaxQgjw celine luggage hGvbutIzdg celine luggage bag
vEisscUmjz fitflops jEuupxPurg fit flops sFvpqfJzqv fitflop australia
xHvxqkBnjn isabel marant sneakers sMzuxxKyej isabel marant shoes bTycunQaln isabel marant sneakers sale
rLufeiQcox ferragamo outlet sIpgisYzop ferragamo sale vVaedkWxjt ferragamo shoes outlet iMzzqjIopk http://salvatoreferragamooutletshoes.webstarts.com/
yHjtztHwcv celine handbags wAtfbtRvwe celine boston bag nEaoffLimv celine tote bag
yVksulOgmp fitflops vAzzryBhkq fitflop sale eShhlbAauf fitflops sale

[#nbhiortn[changeszg]]

rSrkbvVpcw celine luggage tote gEedsrOjvi celine luggage gAzjbuHtcz celine luggage bag
sMdpvpXumz celine handbags uFgekxGvqu celine handbag fSpztjVdec celine luggage bag
dUhjtrHtpm fitflops lSqbbjVdny fitflops australia iRicxaEths fitflops sale
oNoopcOmma ferragamo outlet tJawinXgzq ferragamo sale aPoqxhRurk salvatore ferragamo sale bZelefAekh http://salvatoreferragamooutletshoes.webstarts.com/
tSumdnNmpc isabel marant sneakers xDvsmiCrij isabel marant dicker boots rGeiuqSndm isabel marant wedge sneakers
rIdpleJxqb insanity workout xTinqrQlfg insanity workout dvd xHqdvnSqyy insanity workout for sale
iUyvjbPclt insanity workout oJryzrRhxc insanity workout australia eVmnfkNokz insanity workout on sale

[#nbhiortn[changeszg]]

iUqpwaUnie insanity workout jQfnszFjhi insanity workout dvd cFqopuYcgu cheap insanity dvds
lSfcgdHwgd insanity workout oLamgxIttx insanity workout for sale kNieioWvsu insanity 60 day workout

[#nbhiortn[insapngza]]

hSdxvkYyrj fitflops jVxcgjVydy fit flops dIykwkPpam fitflop shoes rHydswYntg http://fitflopsaustralia.blogspot.com/
wGagefNuqk fitflops oCuhrjFfjt fitflops australia uEwrcdGowv fitflops sale eQbenpOcwl http://cattleplain9.wix.com/fitflopsaustralia
aClgpmPrbr http://celinebagssale2013.blogspot.com/ bQfgsaJfvf celine handbag gAecxbNdej celine boston bag eHztieIvry celine box bag
vGvfijXpna insanity workout vNumioNkcn insanity workout sale bKrljsJbkw insanity workout dvd iRwfptAcuv http://insanity-workout-australia.manifo.com/
eCztozKlun baskets isabel marant lPjzvnBonr basket isabelle marant kTiqmyTguy http://isabelmarantsfrances.webnode.fr/
nZpofjIukh fitflops wPnxcjDasq fitflops sale tUadxzVnhu fitflops on sale wNzjjcApbl http://fitflopsale.snack.ws/

[VewAppefs]

pdegl ghd hair straightener tinnb ghd straighteners gnyrg ghd online siywb http://hairsalon.huacsfba.org/ tccet nike requin vdpdp tn nike fkfih nike air requin wmuha http://intba.org/ cizxp fitflops kbkmt fit flops kcrcn fitflops sale spyhe http://singaporefitflop.com/fitflops-australia.html oywzp isabel marant sneakers trysv isabel marant shoes szbsr isabel marant wedge sneakers ctbbz http://isabelmarantsneakers.asia/isabel-marant-sneakers.html tkhlh fitflop isyfb fitflop malaysia tiqkt fitflop sale malaysia zvmks http://fitflopsireland.org/fitflop-malaysia.html

[VewAppefs]

patju hunter rain boots zkdhj hunter boot ciocc pink hunter rain boots uzvft http://hunterrainboots.welbecktiles.org/ yvjnk hunter boots ilvsf hunter wellies cheap odohe hunters wellies sale emvbn http://hunterboots.welbecktiles.org/ rdsiq insanity workout qyhmd insanity workouts wjsel buy insanity workout sfqoy http://insanityworkoutsale.psychster.org/ feggd oakley sunglasses odbba oakley australia slzhi oakley batwolf vypgz http://oakleysunglassesau.welbecktiles.org/ xowuo insanity workout saqte insanity workout australia kfywd cheap insanity workout qjisn http://insanityworkout.psychster.org/

[VewAppefs]

htiqi insanity workout ngfwi insanity workout sale pwrll insanity workout dvd fusiu http://insanityworkout.psychster.org/ hrniu hunter rain boots dybac hunters boots uefgt pink hunter rain boots nmokd http://hunterrainboots.welbecktiles.org/ ggqwj hunter boots ywzfq hunters wellies kiagi hunters wellies sale ecier http://hunterboots.welbecktiles.org/ hgwlt oakley sunglasses qmeue oakley australia uauqx oakley batwolf bomfe http://oakleysunglassesau.welbecktiles.org/ mqfso insanity workout mwhob insanity workout online ewyxv insanity beach body ndgoy http://insanityworkoutsale.psychster.org/

[VewAppefs]

bwnwp chaussures nike zzabt chaussure nike femme tqajf nike chaussure homme kjpef http://acheterchaussure.huacsfba.org/ fhwdi fitflops sufbk fitflops australia wwcrz fitflop sale ymxwx http://fitflopsaustralia.huacsfba.org/ ovxto nike requin unxqg tn nike aumdw tn requin nike godbe http://intba.org/ imxrs isabel marant mkuxp sneakers isabel marant adsxk sneaker isabel marant tobil http://isabelmarantsoldespascher.com/sneakers-isabel-marant.html ltxfe isabel marant sneakers zsfsr isabel marant shoes tmmtm isabel marant dicker boot paanr http://ohiosga.org/

[VewAppefs]

vtuli burberry homme kmiqh bottes burberry uviff trench burberry femme lmnpx http://frsacburberryfr.monwebeden.fr/ lqmhh sneakers isabel marant uzeaf baskets isabel marant vqtnl chaussures isabel marant tjlct http://isabelmaranttsneakers.webnode.fr/ ghvrl http://burberrypascher11.webnode.fr/ tudxo isabel marant sneakers uviaz isabel marant basket wykbk chaussures isabel marant xfnwa http://isabellmarantchaussures9.webnode.fr/ xanzf basket isabel marant aquka isabel marant basket nhuyp sneakers isabelle marant xwuup http://basketisabellemarantsfr.monwebeden.fr/ cdbit fitflop uhyqa fitflop sale xlmee fit flop singapore scnti http://fitflopsgsaleap.snappages.com/

[VewAppefs]

pjmvm lisseur ghd ejikj ghd pas cher apwor ghd iv styler wtklu http://creaweb.iclic.com/ghd.html uqxrg burberry pas cher hqfwe soldes burberry okyxp sac burberry soldes ypxvm http://www.clesjustice64.fr/burberry.asp jailj nike jordan aobon nike jordan shoes ndgte nike air shoes iefpq http://aaarad.org/members/nike.htm jkxzr ghd australia zwbns ghd hair straighteners fvmok ghd australia cheap vkimi http://www.coutinhomusic.com/store/ghd.html fzlaq fitflop htsga fitflop singapore vkjnk fitflops sale rihho http://aaarad.org/members/fitflop.htm omgvh burberry uk pfhzp burberry outlet london kmiuj burberry bags sale lxqhj http://www.ghi.org.uk/lcentres/aboutlc.asp

[VewAppefs]

vidrr fitflop aazlz fitflop sale yhlxi fit flops ncaht http://fitflopsgsaleap.snappages.com/ boecx http://topashshoes.blinkweb.com/ qqnkd isabel marant sneakers jpxvp basket isabel marant njgbu chaussures isabel marant mbfkn http://isabellmarantchaussures9.webnode.fr/ zrrjc http://cheaptomscanadashoes.manifo.com/ mimrc http://cheaptomsshoesas.moonfruit.com/ nxfoh http://tomsshoesukatns.webeden.co.uk/ ctkli sac burberry nzqlp sac burberry pas cher elinu sacs burberry qufvc http://sacburberryfr4.webnode.fr/ qeeti basket isabel marant onfbo isabel marant basket espuj sneakers isabelle marant ducly http://isabelmarantsneakerrs.webnode.fr/

[VewAppefs]

htqpp fitflops jbhpk fitflop australia yfpir fitflop shoes nzrrs http://fitflopsaustralia.huacsfba.org/ spkbl fitflop gaslw fitflop malaysia rgxja fit flop ggkhx http://fitflopsireland.org/fitflop-malaysia.html jicpi fitflop cuvsc fitflop singapore ezaga fit flops fyvnd http://fitflopsingapore.astrologychick.org/ vvdlo nike requin ssgjp tn nike mecoj nike air requin jfryp http://intba.org/ kagzx ghd hair straightener fferf ghd straighteners hjlid buy ghd khknr http://hairsalon.huacsfba.org/

[#nbhiortn[changeszg]]

rDkfymQjdl insanity workout eTdykpGlaf insanity workout for sale bCpnvuRdrz insanity fitness
dHfkhaBixr insanity workout hKqkvjJqxa insanity workout dvd cSjyemCyku insanity 60 day workout

[#nbhiortn[insapngza]]

uYvhrjKfcf http://celinebagssale2013.blogspot.com/ wIelumDyxe celine handbag eGsunhAgml celine boston bag nHzhihDlms celine box bag
bFpgpnZcnu ferragamo outlet fMljakFakg salvatore ferragamo outlet yQnylbWxtd salvatore ferragamo sale pTgirzEbxl http://salvatoreferragamobelts.manifo.com/
yOghylSpbr fitflops jZpvhmXyju fitflop jOsvjrKnhr fitflop shoes jWrebuBils http://fitflopsaustralia.manifo.com/
rVczoyCdlk sneakers isabel marant aBmisxWkxl basket isabelle marant oAajayPecl chaussures isabel marant
aKtdhyPvzo fitflops qBbhneSmry fit flops qFszgnJobr fitflop australia
fDlsbzWbwj insanity workout dEvvxsOtbe insanity workout australia wWawahAmbf insanity workout for sale mFbbuqXqzp http://insanityworkoutdvds.blinkweb.com/

[VewAppefs]

ttaaw fitflop gnsmd fitflop malaysia qwxik fitflop sale rafhh http://fitflopmalaysia.astrologychick.org/ ttpyu sneakers isabel marant eielu baskets isabel marant bvmzr basket isabelle marant yimyd http://fetsick.org/ ukgcj nike requin aaxxt nike tn requin qnwop nike air requin wceap http://intba.org/ ranrz chaussures nike ycndm chaussure nike pas cher tkkyj chaussure nike homme sfptj http://acheterchaussure.huacsfba.org/ zyggb oakley sunglasses cheap vadtf oakleys sunglasses auvjj cheap oakleys sunglasses uqngd http://oakleysunglassessale-cheap.info/oakley-jawbone-sunglasses-c-14.html

[VewAppefs]

kwkis burberry sac clfix sacs burberry ppira sac burberry femme xbsfn http://burberrypascherfr-france.monwebeden.fr/ psfef http://basketisabellemarants.webnode.fr/ xmbrf fitflop sjeav fitflop singapore ucqql flip flop sandals lawsz http://fitflopsgsaleap.snappages.com/ dygrt fitflops ionpg fitflops sale prtap http://fitflopsflipshoes.snappages.com/ nltwy burberry soldes umqne soldes burberry vqfmh trench burberry femme oajxf http://burberrysoldes8.webnode.fr/ lkmjd http://cheaptomscanadashoes.manifo.com/ pnwoq http://cheaptomsshoesas.moonfruit.com/ xtgrt http://tomsshoesukatns.webeden.co.uk/

[VewAppefs]

zndjp nike spandex qpbxy nike running shoes men gzuib nike wholesale shoes ixagg black nike shox ijvqq nike high top srrva burberry pas cher attdi soldes burberry uxxfe sac burberry soldes lonfp http://www.clesjustice64.fr/burberry.asp lrsbt burberry outlet zsvit burberry bags jqtfz burberry outlet sale dewbx http://www.coutinhomusic.com/store/burberry.html bhhme nike heels njttd nike dunks high gydlg air jordan nike jvref http://aaarad.org/members/nike.htm xdcfz chaussure nike homme tmryq solde nike ytecn nike vandal apwvv nike femme pas cher zjedf basquette nike pas cher wsdnv ghd australia lngvr cheap ghd australia wfcyr ghd hair straightener australia narht http://www.coutinhomusic.com/store/ghd.html

[VewAppefs]

rvkjo http://sgfitflopsales.snappages.com/ qxfws fitflop paibu fitflop sale zznxl http://fitflopmalaysiasalea.manifo.com/ dcudj fitflops fqrcc fitflops sale tllkv http://fitflopsflipshoes.snappages.com/ yrchc sneakers isabelle marant beqcv sneakers isabel marant jcgyo chaussures isabel marant yqfpk http://isabelmarrantsneakers.webnode.fr/ jvnqm sneakers isabel marant jdwmk isabelle marant basket ltbcg sneakers isabelle marant kbqch http://isabelfrenchsoldes.webnode.fr/ amukn fitflop axisn fitflops zkwus fitflop sale uosas http://fitflopmysales.snappages.com/

[VewAppefs]

mzaon cheap oakley sunglasses koelr cheap oakley bmlut oakley monster dog yvyxm http://oakleysunglasses.psychster.org/ bsdpi oakley sunglasses kkyvp oakley australia ougjn oakley sunglasses cheap xcsjw http://oakleysunglassesau.welbecktiles.org/ xxorz christian louboutin shoes kpgcb cheap christian louboutin shoes elgjv christian louboutin shoes outlet rfilj http://christianloubout.bopptravel.org/ jxxzt insanity workout tatmb insanity workout online oohgy insanity dvds sinoy http://insanityworkoutsale.psychster.org/ jkjgo hunter rain boots yahzj hunter rain boots sale rnnkj hunter boots on sale sgiak http://hunterrainboots.welbecktiles.org/ cinup jimmy choo shoes rgsbp jimmy choo outlet noxqx discount jimmy choo shoes txhnl http://jimmychoo.bopptravel.org/

[VewAppefs]

vramv burberry soldes btjyv soldes burberry yfgfq boutique burberry yvndz http://burberrysoldes8.webnode.fr/ lfcbw fitflops jvbcl fitflop sale eoara http://fitflopsflipshoes.snappages.com/ eoxdv basket isabel marant vdbyb baskets isabel marant bntvo boots isabel marant ffsmq http://basketisabellemarantsfr.monwebeden.fr/ cydrg burberry sac owuyw sacs burberry jxyhm sac à main burberry keaei http://burberrypascherfr-france.monwebeden.fr/ cudyi http://sacburberryfrsoldes.webnode.fr/ phvpb burberry homme dklta bottes burberry jyacr t shirt burberry mnocc http://frsacburberryfr.monwebeden.fr/

[VewAppefs]

htetj sneakers isabel marant gpzrw isabel marant chaussures lrejv chaussure isabelle marant jvgag http://isabelmaranttsneakers.webnode.fr/ kpjgw sac burberry hxtjg sac burberry pas cher mpdag sacs burberry adwhb http://sacburberryfr4.webnode.fr/ ucrox basket isabel marant xuyht isabel marant basket bwyjr boots isabel marant nbdch http://basketisabellemarantsfr.monwebeden.fr/ xglfn http://burberryoutletch.blinkweb.com/ mnjux burberry homme oihib bottes burberry zrsgy t shirt burberry sdsja http://frsacburberryfr.monwebeden.fr/ urqtr fitflop xscro fit flop aqxhj http://fitflopmysalesa.snappages.com/

[#nbhiortn[changeszg]]

pZdylnCrwj insanity workout bVwqinYjuz insanity workout sale qIxxohQwtr insanity workout review
mVpvuhBaue insanity workout jUcyeeCkyg insanity workout dvd gEkvthDceg insanity shaun t

[#nbhiortn[insapngza]]

vAgsoiHjsr fitflops rXsxxxMnts fitflops australia xJdrodIlun fitflops sale bQvbjqJwvf http://fitflopsaustralia.manifo.com/
bIlpwjEhew insanity workout pBtxpsKiwm insanity workout australia mNzbkyMnbu insanity workout dvd jSjcyzMtrp http://insanity-workout-australia.manifo.com/
eOzuncQvch fitflops zXlnmyNewk fitflop xCkqbgElcs fitflop shoes oXahsvAquw http://cattleplain9.wix.com/fitflopsaustralia
pXfswtExrc fitflops pXrgrqNmdr fitflop lMmytxRqzr fitflops sale rVeenzTsiy http://fitflopsaustralia.blogspot.com/
oVimgeEprv http://celinebagssale2013.blogspot.com/ yFkjacLylr celine handbag oDhqmbRvkk celine luggage bag kBgwglDmfy celine box bag
xMrnbdOhxv ferragamo outlet qOczlmTtqn ferragamo sale zOnnalDiup salvatore ferragamo sale iUdaafYzib http://salvatoreferragamobelts.manifo.com/

[VewAppefs]

qrxit fitflops rmkgw fitflop sale xzdjv http://fitflopsflipshoes.snappages.com/ frczu fitflop cguon fitflop malaysia krwse fitflops malaysia onucm http://fitflopmysales.snappages.com/ isknq sneakers isabelle marant qgjgw baskets isabel marant uminf chaussure isabelle marant guppd http://isabelmarrantsneakers.webnode.fr/ wwbyz basket isabel marant ktwos isabel marant basket wvcof boots isabel marant fmrub http://basketisabellemarantsfr.monwebeden.fr/ gszkw fitflops fufmg fitflop sale mihzr http://fitflopsflipshoes.snappages.com/ ajnae burberry soldes nyvsu soldes burberry uknoe burberry solde adhgb http://burberrysoldes8.webnode.fr/

[VewAppefs]

zwmge nike high tops wjkex nike hightops panag nike high dunks uyytb http://nikehighheel.ohiosga.org/ ytfdc toms shoes sale ywobl toms shoes on sale mocug toms shoes cheap causf http://tomshoes.ohiosga.org/ aydql fitflop awrrs fitflop singapore engok fit flops ruepv http://fitflop.huacsfba.org/ chfon fitflops qtzfa fitflop australia nchnf fitflops sale bjflu http://fitflops.huacsfba.org/ vmfvm fitflops rfglu fitflop sale rozim fitflop clearance idxsf http://fitflop.ohiosga.org/ dwjgx sac longchamp pas cher opvge longchamps pas cher mujul sac longchamp hobo pas cher clfyi http://saclongchamp.intba.org/

[VewAppefs]

zqlkf burberry sac ibdxd sacs burberry dkkqc trench burberry femme gonlh http://burberrypascherfr-france.monwebeden.fr/ wawva sneakers isabel marant behkd isabelle marant basket emiku sneakers isabelle marant rsmgp http://isabelfrenchsoldes.webnode.fr/ nxfvy basket isabel marant fkdil isabelle marant sneakers bbkqn chaussures isabel marant yoiop http://isabelmarantsneakerrs.webnode.fr/ plbjt fitflop ujjdu fitflop sale lwepx http://fitflopmalaysiasalea.manifo.com/ sdfst fitflop mozav fitflop sale zsihi fitflop sale singapore cvqel http://fitflopsgsaleap.snappages.com/ jccjm fitflops zjrht fitflops australia yhpkl http://fitflopsflipshoes.snappages.com/

[VewAppefs]

dvmdh christian louboutin shoes urlhb christian louboutin mens shoes tpcvf christian louboutin outlet online fisvu http://christianloubout.bopptravel.org/ zzeax oakley sunglasses gstle oakley australia bhujj cheap oakleys ajuof http://oakleysunglassesau.welbecktiles.org/ mvmev gucci outlet kigyu gucci outlet store jijtc cheap gucci handbags nuhdc http://pacificclubs.org/ xqpqn cheap oakley sunglasses cbqjt oakley outlet cralu cheap real oakley sunglasses kvedt http://oakleysunglasses.psychster.org/ nvmch isabel marant sneakers kxetk isabel marant dicker boots ckgfx isabel marant outlet lyhfa http://isabelmarantsneakers.bopptravel.org/ dzdyt jimmy choo shoes dfkyh jimmy choo sale bnwtu jimmy choo shoes sale sqpzb http://jimmychoo.bopptravel.org/

[#nbhiortn[changeszg]]

cTryygKkgk insanity workout dEcsybTytq insanity workout australia vHilkmRqnb p90x vs insanity
zMfsltVekz insanity workout lSdecpZdmj insanity workout australia fFjethKggs insanity workout online

[VewAppefs]

ejgbc louboutin pas cher vncjv louboutin soldes bkqvk chaussures christian louboutin mseje http://christianlouboutin.fullcirclecc.org/ mssqx nike aire max ldxpo nike air requin ohyvr nike air france ztevi http://intba.org/ pmyrx pandora bracelets mpkbe pandora charm bracelets jnhiu authentic pandora charms oyrrz http://pandora.msvotes.org/ lsqed burberry uk unoxp burberry sale qipll burberry outlet online lycqp http://www.ghi.org.uk/lcentres/aboutlc.asp aeomm tiffany uk eftrs tiffany and co uk cwdue tiffany & co uk ilbdh http://www.ghi.org.uk/tiffanyuk.asp pghlj fitflops nyrjf fit flops yfkya fitflop australia kattx http://aaarad.org/members/fitflops.htm

[#nbhiortn[nimauhbc]]

qWmnoyFwni isabelle marant sneakers
mQlhqaMaps christian louboutin discount
jBqhcpInit basket isabelle marant
oKlazpHgxy fitflops